Subscribe
Notify of
guest

390 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Leo
Leo (@guest_1659280)
July 24, 2023 17:38

Looks like this is still working, they never shut it down.

Jim
Jim (@guest_1659406)
July 24, 2023 20:44

I’ve been able to log in and even add banks, but can’t initiate any transfers.

Have tried every month or two since they “shut down”

Leo

Jack
Jack (@guest_1686858)
September 6, 2023 06:52

Leo Jim Same here. I can add banks, so it’s “working” in that regard, but I can’t actually do transfers.

Jason
Jason (@guest_1604229)
April 22, 2023 23:47

Does anyone know of a similar service?

fdic
fdic (@guest_1571044)
March 7, 2023 19:08

Anyone else get this email today?

Bank Account Requires Reauthorization

XXXXXX,

Something is not right. Your Bank Account needs to be reconnected to Astra. You can reconnect your account here.

Bank: XXXXXXXX Bank
Account(s): XXXXXXXX- xxxxxx, and so on

Is there any way to ask these guys to delete my data? I already deleted everything from the app when they were shutting down but of course they still retain all the account numbers etc

Kaching
Kaching (@guest_1571107)
March 7, 2023 21:10

I’ve received these emails 4 times today and about 4 times in the past month. I deleted everything from the app too. I think it may have something to do with Juno, since Juno apparently uses Astra to process some bank to bank transactions. I’ve noticed this ever since I signed up with Juno. Do you have a Juno account too?

dmachop
dmachop (@guest_1621890)
May 22, 2023 08:07

@Kaching you’re right. It’s juno.

Davis
Davis (@guest_1555676)
February 13, 2023 13:35

Is anybody else still having Astra process transfers? I’ve tried to contact them to cancel my transaction but nobody answers

Venkatesh Appala
Venkatesh Appala (@guest_1556948)
February 15, 2023 09:12

Yes it’s working still for me.

Jack
Jack (@guest_1559110)
February 18, 2023 09:11

Venkatesh Appala By working, you can still successfully complete transfers using Astra as a middleman?

Jack
Jack (@guest_1559108)
February 18, 2023 09:10

Davis Why were you trying to do a transfer so long after they said it would be discontinued?

LEGOProBuilder
LEGOProBuilder (@guest_1618123)
May 15, 2023 02:21

Davis you might be able to cancel the routines at https://app.astra.finance/

Tom
Tom (@guest_1494370)
November 23, 2022 07:26

Hi guys, my name is Tom, and I am one of the co-founders of Sequence. I saw we were mentioned here and just wanted to elaborate more on the product:

Sequence a is the first of its kind Financial Router. It lets you build a custom architecture for your cash flow.
By routing your income sources into it and setting smart rules and IF statements, you can control precisely how much, when, and where you want to route your funds.

Here is what Sequence is about in a nutshell:

1. It makes your money visual. Sequence UI is designed as a ‘Money map’ to help you visualize exactly how your money flows. What you can see, you can manage.
2. Consolidation. By directing all your income sources into one place and seeing exactly where this money is going, you get a holistic view of your finances. This view can be of your personal finances, household, business, or all of them at once. Whatever fits your needs.
3. Smart and specific. Setting conditionals (IF statements) to your money flow opens up a whole new level of control. Set granular rules to control precisely when, how much, and where your money should go.
4. Actionable. Move money and take action straight from Sequence.

The product is currently in Alpha stage, and we are onboarding users that are interested in giving feedback.
If anyone is interested or has any questions, feel free to email me at: [email protected]

You can find more information on our website: https://www.getsequence.io/.

Thanks

fdic
fdic (@guest_1494483)
November 23, 2022 10:25

Hi.. Welcome. To be honest, that is a bit expensive for a service in alpha and if you want feedback from the users. You know there are very capable and sharp people here who will find every single bug for you : )

Brandon Liu
Brandon Liu (@guest_1494551)
November 23, 2022 12:35

Agreed, would you consider a free tier or trial? It sure would let people on the fence like me sign up and see for themselves if it’s worth the money first. More sign ups for sure

Tom
Tom (@guest_1494576)
November 23, 2022 13:16

For early adopters and as long as the product is in the Alpha stage, we are offering the Unlimited Business & Personal tier ($34.97/month) for the price of the Starter tier ($8.73/month).

Jack
Jack (@guest_1495176)
November 24, 2022 13:09

Can you make a free tier please?

Frank S
Frank S (@guest_1531893)
January 12, 2023 11:08

They are making progress, and I’m excited about the app in general, but they have a long way to go. Most of the best financial institutions are not integrated, so you can only send ACH and can’t use them for automations in the other direction.

killdozer
killdozer (@guest_1493873)
November 22, 2022 15:44

Is there anyway to unlink linked accounts and close account with “getwellpaid”? Just like Astra, its got no support / csr and does not work. I unlinked my accounts on Astra and closed accounts, but getwellpaid still has all these accounts linked. No way to remove them or close the account. Of course, no response from support tickets. Very sketch.

Bockrr
Bockrr (@guest_1495967)
November 25, 2022 17:17

I have a duplicate account showing in both and tried Wellpaid support to ask about removing accounts and/or resetting to a blank slate. They responded 3 days later to say they would think about such a feature. I kinda got the impression Astra is sunsetting their app because they don’t want to do end user support but their partners customer support isn’t much better. I still might try it for a month, I mean it’s only $3.

killdozer
killdozer (@guest_1495969)
November 25, 2022 17:19

I cant even get a response from wellpaid, im worried about vulnerabilities especially with the Astra app being abandoned and wellpaid keeping bank links open and no way to remove them.

Bockrr
Bockrr (@guest_1504613)
December 8, 2022 05:57

killdozer Best option might be to disconnect Wellpaid and Astra via the Plaid consumer portal. After trying to get accounts in order on Wellpaid I now have even more duplicate accounts with no way to fix. Not ready for prime time.

https://my.plaid.com/

bankbonus
bankbonus (@guest_1488927)
November 15, 2022 18:51

Got an email that Sequence (mentioned below) is accepting signups. They’re offering the business plan (150 transfers) for $9/month. Might be worth checking out at that price

lilurbanachiever
lilurbanachiever (@guest_1488834)
November 15, 2022 16:58

Can anybody confirm that Astra is still working ? And perhaps also still triggers Sofi bonus ? Thanks.

Anthony
Anthony (@guest_1488847)
November 15, 2022 17:11

I just sent multiple transactions via Astra with Payroll as the name to Sofi. Sofi is still registering them as direct deposit. Awaiting bonus for 100% confirmation, but it did work to trigger my higher interest rate, so that should be confirmation enough.

Luke
Luke (@guest_1488893)
November 15, 2022 18:09

Anthony did you do recurring routine or one time transfer routine?

L
L (@guest_1493554)
November 22, 2022 09:39

Luke I did a one time.

L
L (@guest_1493553)
November 22, 2022 09:39

lilurbanachiever Still works as of Nov 8th when I last pushed a deposit.

Luke
Luke (@guest_1493764)
November 22, 2022 13:56
  L

I did a one time and it didn’t work, posted as a merchant transaction. I have a recurring one going to see what happens.

L
L (@guest_1494629)
November 23, 2022 14:49

Luke Did you make sure to name the transfer “Payroll”? It won’t work otherwise. I was doing one time transfers too.

Luke
Luke (@guest_1497430)
November 28, 2022 14:50
  L

I did both a one time and 2 recurring transfer routines named as Payroll. None of them showed up as DD for SoFi.

Jay
Jay (@guest_1499218)
December 1, 2022 00:31

I just had one go to SoFi today (was trying for dec) and it landed as Deposit. I have another in motion that will certainly land in a few days as Deposit…

Wont be able to get that final month of DD in…

Bockrr
Bockrr (@guest_1483733)
November 8, 2022 18:39

 Chuck  William Charles Diego AllenW Gorgonzola (sorry Jay can’t find you)

I think this must be new, an “app” called Wellpaid mentioned on the Astra site. It actually doesn’t seem to be an app (yet) but web based. For now at least it’s free to make single transfers and they are asking $3/month for recurring and advanced stuff. I opened an account here:
https://app.getwellpaid.com/sign-up
I signed in with phone number and all my accounts from Astra were already populated.

As you can see it’s pretty much Astra in a website:
https://imgur.com/a/E3TQPsE

For $3 I might be willing to pay, although it seems you could do everything manually for free, for now anyway. Depends how many accounts and transfers you need to manage.

Bockrr
Bockrr (@guest_1483741)
November 8, 2022 18:47

Update: Apparently one time transfer requires the monthly fee also, or at least it tries to charge it when I schedule one.

AllenW
AllenW (@guest_1483765)
November 8, 2022 19:12

Hmm very interesting. Have you made a transfer yet to see if it truncates the description.

I see the $3 fee. Min monthly $3.

If there is a bonus requirement next month for me to use this I will test it.

Luke
Luke (@guest_1485805)
November 11, 2022 13:45

Any DP on this yet? I’m looking for something for SoFi. I was late to the Astra app. I was able to download it but I’m stuck at $100 limit. I don’t even know if I can connect banks and transfer on it. My money is in Upgrade and it doesn’t seem I can connect it to Astra to get it to SoFi. Can I do SoFi to SoFi through Astra with a P2 account?

Bockrr
Bockrr (@guest_1485990)
November 11, 2022 19:08

I don’t see Upgrade in Astra accounts area, does it not support Plaid? Anything Astra doesn’t support in turn won’t be supported by this Wellpaid service which is relying on Astra’s API.

Astra is meant to transfer between accounts with the same owner. If you attempt SoFi to SoFi between accounts with different owners you may encounter issues, fraud holds, etc. But I don’t know that anyone has tried.

Luke
Luke (@guest_1486012)
November 11, 2022 20:01

Astra wouldn’t let me even link P2’s account. I just transferred my money from Upgrade to Ally. I’ll have to figure out what to do with it to get it to DD to SoFi. Waiting on DP in Wellpaid whether it counts as DD.

Gorgonzola
Gorgonzola (@guest_1504738)
December 8, 2022 10:27

I signed up to check it out. Buggy so far, not unlike Astra. Getting some errors on the webpage but as you said, it had all my connected accounts in Astra. I was thinking about disconnecting all of them in the Astra app before it dies for good, but may keep them connected to try this out. I was trying to connect My Wells Fargo account through Wellpaid and it took me through all the steps and said connected but it’s been a few hours and still hasn’t show up in my accounts. If I can get that connected I’ll try a transfer and see how much I can do for free and if it codes as DD.

Bockrr
Bockrr (@guest_1481245)
November 6, 2022 18:45

It’s a bit buried but Gorgonzola mentioned that support told him just two weeks ago a new app was incoming?

Gorgonzola
Gorgonzola (@guest_1481266)
November 6, 2022 19:37

I guess I made that assumption from what they told me. They basically said that I had the beta app and “exciting new things were in the works for Astra users!” so I took that as a non-beta app was coming. I wasn’t expecting it to be shut down from what they told me.