Subscribe
Notify of
guest

327 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Greg
Greg (@guest_2069986)
May 31, 2025 00:43

Many of you transfer in securities via ACAT and receive the bonus?

The Terms do not state the often “USD or equivalent securities”

>…fund their tastytrade account with $2,000 USD or more, and (2) existing customers who have never funded any tastytrade account prior to the start of the Promotional Period, and who fund their existing brokerage account with $2,000 USD or more 

lesliefarms
lesliefarms (@guest_2068707)
May 28, 2025 12:38

declined to open account because I had an account previously

Naddi
Naddi (@guest_2067835)
May 26, 2025 19:21

TT is ok for the bonus but I’m not a fan of them as a long-term brokerage. Their website is not as full-featured as other sites. One major lacking feature is the ability to pick lots to be sold for tax purposes. The major brokerages allow this but not TT.

Houstonian
Houstonian (@guest_2067851)
May 26, 2025 20:22

Which one has this may I asked? I recently transfer to Robinhood and they lumped all the stocks together and I cannot pick the lot accordingly unless manually

Naddi
Naddi (@guest_2067961)
May 27, 2025 04:30

Schwab, Interactive Brokers, Merrill Edge, Vanguard allow it.

Doctor Mario
Doctor Mario (@guest_2068006)
May 27, 2025 09:35

Fidelity allows it.

Rugy
Rugy (@guest_2068395)
May 27, 2025 20:47

Not being able to choose your lots is ridiculous.

Ty K.
Ty K. (@guest_2067680)
May 26, 2025 11:58

Is Tastytrade same as Tastyworks?

If I had gotten bonus from Tastyworks before, is this still churnable?

niadnf
niadnf (@guest_2067703)
May 26, 2025 12:46

They are the same. I don’t believe it is currently churnable.

TJ
TJ (@guest_2067755)
May 26, 2025 15:24

It is the same , and it never was churnable, so not sure what you mean by “still”. Once per lifetime. I wasted mine on 100 free stocks before they even had a 2k for 100k offer.

JD
JD (@guest_2067975)
May 27, 2025 06:40
  TJ

How much did they end up being worth? I also wasted mine on the $500 for 10k. However, there are some DPs that you can ask them and they will allow you to earn one of the higher tier bonuses (less your original bonus amount).

earl
earl (@guest_2067653)
May 26, 2025 10:58

I’m going to hand $500,000+, for a year, to people who decided that TastyTrade was the best name for a brokerage?

I think not.

RD
RD (@guest_2067891)
May 26, 2025 22:05

Well people are handing their money to Robinhood, named after a thief.

Anyway TT has been more of a credible entity than most of the newfangled brokerages that are popping up.

JM
JM (@guest_2067972)
May 27, 2025 05:42

Why are you depositing $500k when the max bonus is for $100k deposit?

JD
JD (@guest_2067973)
May 27, 2025 06:30
  JM

There are bonuses for 250k, 500k, and 1MM too…where do you see 100k max?

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067989)
May 27, 2025 08:38
  JD

True, but also: If you have $500k and access to 5 players, you could get $10k bonuses total, vs $4k bonus for single player. God bless large families.

JD
JD (@guest_2067996)
May 27, 2025 09:04

lol…you mean like Warren Jeffs’?

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2068035)
May 27, 2025 10:30
  JD

I’m single myself, but I do have parents and siblings, at least some of whom I trust and vice versa …

niadnf
niadnf (@guest_2068089)
May 27, 2025 12:07

Moomoo has entered the chat

Thelen
Thelen (@guest_2067625)
May 26, 2025 09:21

Have gotten the $500 bonus and a $500 referral bonus with both paid quickly. There have been other bonuses I’ve tried to get with a partial transfer to Tradeup and Webull but both have failed because it seems APEX clearing (tastytrade) and Omnibus systems (Webull/Tradeup) don’t do partial transfers. As a warning though – their duuble authentication system stupidly only applies to withdrawals and a few other actions – BUT NOT TO LOGGING IN even at new devices. That means someone can guess your password and get in and wreck your account with bad trades either for fun or apparently they can funnel bad trades with large spreads to their other accounts to earn a profit. I didn’t believe it but tested it with my own account and was able to log in at a random device with no authentication.

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067667)
May 26, 2025 11:24

Do you have 2FA enabled on your account? Look under MyProfile>Security.

Thelen
Thelen (@guest_2067854)
May 26, 2025 20:41

It is enabled and I have to use it to withdraw – but you can’t turn it on for logging in.

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2068041)
May 27, 2025 10:37

Hmm, that IS weird. Best to have a very strong password. Hopefully they have lockout for repeated failed attempts.

Geoff
Geoff (@guest_2067520)
May 25, 2025 20:14

Have to hold the money there for over a year:

The initial minimum funding amount of $2,000 USD to $1,000,0000 USD deposited into a Qualified Customer’s Qualified Account is required to remain in the Qualified Account for a minimum of twelve (12) months starting the date the Qualified Account meets the funding minimum (“Twelve Month Period”). The value of Cash Bonus the Qualified Customer receives will be credited to its Qualified Account upon deposit, but will be automatically debited out of the Qualified Customer’s Qualified Account if the Twelve-Month Period requirement is not met.

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067668)
May 26, 2025 11:27

True, but it’s not a 12-month vacation for your money. Put it to work, even if it’s just SGOV, or whatever you’d normally invest in. Bail if you find something better in the future. Seize the day.

Charles Mann
Charles Mann (@guest_2067819)
May 26, 2025 18:44

Indeed!

catcat
catcat (@guest_2067433)
May 25, 2025 15:28

It looks like the promotion is live again. Same promo code MYNEWBONUS and same tiers as before.  William Charles  Chuck

THE PROMOTION PERIOD 
The Promotion begins at 12:00am CT on 05/19/2025 and ends at 11:59pm CT on 08/31/2025 (the “Promotional Period”). Sponsor’s computer is the official clock for the Promotion.

SP
SP (@guest_2067526)
May 25, 2025 21:16

If I read it correctly it is $2000 bonus for holding $100K for 12 months which is just 2%. Doesn’t look worth it even if we buy some T-bills or so. could put the $100K to much better use with other churns I believe. I may be wrong though 🙂

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067663)
May 26, 2025 11:20
  SP

Um, why not invest the $100k you send to Tasty in Treasury ETF(s), earn income on the ETF plus get the bonus? And, if something better comes along, bail on Tasty? tl;dr: You can have your cake and eat it too.

catcat
catcat (@guest_2067672)
May 26, 2025 11:44
  SP

SP IMO it’s not a bad offer if you already have your assets in securities like stocks, etfs, etc but agreed it’s not the best offer for holding cash/treasuries.

One thing to note is that Schwab was willing to match this offer for P2 but at the $3k/$250k level. Still 1 year hold at Schwab but you would get more options like having treasury auctions and trading mutual funds.

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067721)
May 26, 2025 13:31

“not the best offer for holding cash/treasuries” — taking into account the zillion or so ETFs that are the functional equivalent thereof?

catcat
catcat (@guest_2067725)
May 26, 2025 13:41

tuphat Sorry I may have misspoke – I’m actually a novice with this stuff and have only dealt with short-term treasury bond ETFs. What kind of investments would be good for holding cash in this account?

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067737)
May 26, 2025 14:18

Many people like 1-3m Treasury ETFs like SGOV and BIL, or other short duration bond ETFs like NEAR and BSV.

Alternatively, you could use your cash to chase a bank/CU HYSA bonus periodically found on DoC.

SP
SP (@guest_2067785)
May 26, 2025 17:08

Last option is what I was talking about. You can get more outside rather than binding the money in tasty trade where you would have invest.

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067796)
May 26, 2025 17:32
  SP

fwiw –

(1) Personally, I wouldn’t look at it as “binding the money” when you can walk any time you feel like it (sorta like my ex-girlfriends).

(2) As you likely know, decent bonuses for highest-yielding savings accts are relatively rare, at least compared to checking, but the current 1st timer at Discover may be one of those.

https://www.doctorofcredit.com/discover-savings-150200-bonus-1500020000-deposit-new-exp-103117/

SP
SP (@guest_2067784)
May 26, 2025 17:06

Tasty trade offer is only on cash right and not assets?

catcat
catcat (@guest_2067793)
May 26, 2025 17:26
  SP

SP No it is for securities too. P2 is currently doing this offer with t-bills and SGOV.

wilsonhammer
wilsonhammer (@guest_2063749)
May 19, 2025 14:12

A heads up that this brokerage has the terrible policy to require full SSNs for a transfer on death (TOD) designation form. At least they have a secure document upload option. Good thing my funds won’t be with them forever!

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067661)
May 26, 2025 11:17

I think you will find that most brokers these days, for NEW ACCOUNTS, will require TINs for TOD beneficiaries. I think this is due to multiple reasons, incl. FDIC rules for banks to maintain TINs for POD beneficiaries in their records, and the perceived “best practice” for brokers to do the same for TOD accounts.

wilsonhammer
wilsonhammer (@guest_2067713)
May 26, 2025 13:22

yeah, except none of that is true. plenty of big brokers don’t require (fidelity, vanguard, etrade, I could go on) even for new accounts. this outfit is just crappy through and through. also, schwab does not require TINs for bank account bennies.

you shouldn’t have to give or ask for a SSN except for your spouse, minor dependent, employer, or lender

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067730)
May 26, 2025 14:12

Not disputing your observations, just adding this:

In December 2024, the FDIC published a proposed rule which, among other things, requires banks to maintain TINs of beneficiaries. (This in the wake of Synapse; rule not yet finalized). The prop rule has various exemptions, incl one for broker accounts.

I think many (most?) regular banks have effectively “pre-adopted” the rule in their onboarding processes. I can also easily see — at least in “normal” policymaking times — this approach being implemented more widely, perhaps by FINRA and/or SIPC, at some point.

wilsonhammer
wilsonhammer (@guest_2067744)
May 26, 2025 14:33

ah. Thanks for that context! hopefully they still have some provisions for ppl who don’t have SSNs (I see something in there about “foreign identification number” ?). still, seems like a pretty stupid requirement to mandate giving the keys to the kingdom to someone for your entire life just because they want you to inherit some funds should they die. have the feds learned nothing from rampant identity theft?

https://www.fdic.gov/board/rin-3064-ag07-notice-proposed-rule-notice-proposed-rulemaking-custodial-deposit-accounts

tuphat
tuphat (@guest_2067800)
May 26, 2025 17:38

Totally personal view but: I assumed long ago that my SSN and most other PII were available on the DW.

PS. For fun, you could always use the famous Woolworths SSN, but I don’t think that’s entirely Kosher.

wilsonhammer
wilsonhammer (@guest_2067850)
May 26, 2025 20:11

Agreed on that, but I don’t increase the risk by handing it out more than necessary

Lololol. Maybe all zeroes?

David
David (@guest_2048933)
April 23, 2025 20:56

how long do I have the hold the money in the account?

SP
SP (@guest_2067527)
May 25, 2025 21:16

12 months or you will forfeit the bonus(could be for just the remaining period).