Subscribe
Notify of
guest
The comment form collects your name, email and content to allow us keep track of the comments placed on the website.

48 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Fish
Fish (@guest_2135003)
September 3, 2025 11:49

If I initiate ACAT transfer (over $10,000 each) from three different brokerages into Robinhood, will RH refund the transfer fees from all three transfers?

wjl2525
wjl2525 (@guest_2132927)
August 31, 2025 19:51

If I have to withdraw all the deposit in the fourth year, am I still eligible for 60% of the bonus(accounting for the first three years) or 100% will be clawed back given I don’t meet the 5 year requirement?

dave
dave (@guest_2131514)
August 29, 2025 16:13

I am just finishing up the WeBull 3% bonus terms so this is perfect timing to move to Robinhood.

5 years is a long time though.

Are we able to withdraw the promo bonus, dividends and interest without affecting the terms of the bonus. I tried reading the T&C but it s not clear to me.

calwatch
calwatch (@guest_2133645)
September 1, 2025 19:44

As long as your balance is greater than the amount prior to transfer day plus the transferred amount plus the bonus you should be good.

Joe
Joe (@guest_2131234)
August 29, 2025 10:30

Does anyone know how the 5 year period works if you’ve done prior bonuses? E.g. if I transferred 100K in 2024, 100K in earlier bonus in 2025 and 100K now. If I pull money out in 2029 when the 2024 bonus is up do I then lose the bonus I got in 2025? I’ve done a bunch of these and am just not sure if it is “last in first out”

Craig
Craig (@guest_2130695)
August 28, 2025 15:55

This deal (and the Webull deal) are enticing – but how in the world can I trust these institutions with irreplaceable funds that I will depend on in retirement if they can’t even run a proper beneficiary system? Webull does not even to primary beneficiaries properly and Robinhood does not allow contingent beneficiaries. These systems are not properly equipped to manage lifetime money IMO.

G
G (@guest_2130436)
August 28, 2025 10:07

For me personally, I’m really tempted:
1) Already working on or recently completed other majors ones like tasytrade, moomoo, webull, etc
2) Fortunate to still have quite a lot of assets to pump into this (tempted for $1m), and plenty left over for churning other bonuses as needed. $1m over 5 years at 3% would get $30k or $6k/year
3) Confident I won’t need to touch that within the next 5 years
4) Have IRA already in RH from last match (not that this matters much)
5) My vague understanding is that stocks are safer than cash in a failing brokerage – stocks are at risk primarily if there is major illegal activity which I think is quite unlikely (obviously not 0% though)

Now why did I bore you with this comment – looking for anyone to poke holes in this thinking

Garpered
Garpered (@guest_2130823)
August 28, 2025 20:16
  G

I’m in the exact same boat. Extremely tempted but how much counterparty risk am I taking???

Elaz
Elaz (@guest_2130919)
August 29, 2025 00:12
  G

They have excess sipc. insurance that kicks in after SIPC is exhausted … downside is that it’s $1B max… and the insurer is Lloyd’s of London.

They have $200B AUM, so $1B might help a bit… but obviously wouldn’t be enough to cover a complete and total loss of all aum … but that is an unlikely scenario.

For cash there is different insurance that covers Robinhood .. FDIC etc..

I feel safer with Robin Hood then I do with webull.. the Chinese connection there makes it a little scarier for me.

Here’s a link to all their insurance products and how your protected.

https://robinhood.com/us/en/support/articles/how-youre-protected/

magnet
magnet (@guest_2130209)
August 27, 2025 22:13

I don’t see any reason to do this instead of WeBull’s 2% bonus unless you have over $1,000,000 in transferable assets, but even then the 5 year requirement is a bit much

Elaz
Elaz (@guest_2130921)
August 29, 2025 00:19

Webull has a Chinese connection and has had some senate investigations. It matters to me, maybe not others.

Main benefit of this over webull is that you get everything upfront .. webull bonus is spread out in equal increments over 24 months.
Your return on a $20k bonus will likely be $2k in year 1… vs like $600-700 in year 1 at webull… (assuming 10% returns for easier math).

Raylan G
Raylan G (@guest_2130053)
August 27, 2025 18:15

Haven’t they run a 3% bonus before? Or am I misremembering?

Matt Katakis
Matt Katakis (@guest_2130215)
August 27, 2025 22:24

That was for retirement accounts. This is their highest they’ve offered for brokerage.

mrfnuts
mrfnuts (@guest_2129894)
August 27, 2025 13:15

Since you’re getting a 1099-MISC, is the bonus going to a regular (accessible before I’m 59.5) account? Or is that going to go inside of the IRA as well?

Celery
Celery (@guest_2130317)
August 28, 2025 02:20

No IRAs involved here, this is for regular brokerage.

Calvin
Calvin (@guest_2129877)
August 27, 2025 12:50

Do you need to transfer 100k in one shot for the 3% transfer bonus? Or can you make multiple transfers that cumulatively add up?

Derek J
Derek J (@guest_2130028)
August 27, 2025 17:31

Just FYI, my understanding is that you need to maintain a margin balance of 100k for the 3% (I.E borrow 100k at margin IR at the point of transfer to meet the 3% match offer)

Nis pat
Nis pat (@guest_2130045)
August 27, 2025 17:59

And to add to the previous comment, You don’t have to keep that margin going. I have done 2% bonus with Robinhood and I paid margin balance or sold stocks after transfer to remove margin.

Derek J
Derek J (@guest_2130076)
August 27, 2025 18:50

Can you give me step by step instructions on how you did this?

Is it basically:
1) apply for 100k margin balance.
2) Draw 100k balance (buy SGOV).
3) Initial transfer from external brokerage (100k+)
4) Wait for transfer to clear.
5) Sell SGOV to pay margin balance and any applicable interest?

Nis pat
Nis pat (@guest_2130114)
August 27, 2025 19:41

Yes that’s right. When you start process from Robinhood it will let you select margin balance in acats. You won’t get bonus on that 100k margin transfer but will get it on the rest of the transfer

rebecca
rebecca (@guest_2130448)
August 28, 2025 10:32

Sorry to be redundant, but if you do this, you get a 3% bonus on the ENTIRE amount transferred? Thank you

Pb
Pb (@guest_2130480)
August 28, 2025 11:32

could you instead transfer 100k+ first, then apply for the 100k margin balance to lock in the 3%?