Subscribe
Notify of
guest

74 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

djfly
djfly (@guest_1557276)
February 15, 2023 18:36

 William Charles are we allowed to post referral links like Riz posted above?

Jasonj
Jasonj (@guest_1557268)
February 15, 2023 18:32

Ha now you can post ref link here ?!

William Charles
Admin
February 15, 2023 18:35

No

Steve
Steve (@guest_1536655)
January 18, 2023 11:11

Can we open up the Referral thread for the new $100 bonus offer?  Chuck

Steve
Steve (@guest_1536668)
January 18, 2023 11:21

Roger that.

HarryTheFirstHarry
HarryTheFirstHarry (@guest_1537053)
January 18, 2023 17:29

I would second the request to open the thread annually at this time when the Marcus bonus runs not just for the reason that I opened my first account and want to post my referral link but when I looked into the existing thread, I had to scroll several levels down to find posts by well known doc contributers and even if I were to use any links from unknown people at the top, likely they would have closed their accounts with the result that the referral would get wasted.

William Charles
Admin
January 18, 2023 17:57

Moderating referrals just takes too much time, we can’t constantly be opening and closing threads and taking hours and hours of our time to make sure people don’t break the rules.

djfly
djfly (@guest_1557202)
February 15, 2023 17:09

 William Charles Then why not remove the referral thread altogether? Can’t help but be salty that some users even newer and with almost zero contribution have locked down their referral link on your site while others who probably contribute regularly can never get a chance to post theirs. Kinda unfair.

William Charles
Admin
February 15, 2023 18:43

Because keeping the current links there doesn’t take any effort what so ever, whereas opening them up or deleting it entirely does. I’m sorry that it makes you upset but there is only so much time in the day for me to run this website and I have a job and life outside of it.

djfly
djfly (@guest_1557311)
February 15, 2023 19:21

 William Charles I totally understand the time and effort constraint. But it’s unfair to many of your followers and active users who can’t post while some selected few will keep getting benefited. It should be all or none. That’s just what I think. Of course your site, your rules!

William Charles
Admin
February 15, 2023 19:48

I don’t really think it’s that unfair, we kept the original referral post open for almost TWO years. We closed it once people breaking the rules started eating up too much time. You’re welcome to use other active referral threads and share your link there.

The alternative isn’t that we delete just that page, it’s that we ban all referrals on the site entirely. Is that honestly what you would prefer?

djfly
djfly (@guest_1557423)
February 15, 2023 21:36

 William Charles But new users keep pouring in to follow you? They wouldn’t have been around in those two years? They don’t stand to have same participation?

I understand people are breaking rules, so solution should be either actively ban such users or level the playing field with no referrals at all. Admittedly managing these threads and actively banning is hard.

I’m sure my personal opinion doesn’t decide this, but since you asked, yes, I’d honestly prefer no referrals on the site entirely over unfair advantage to the few.

William Charles
Admin
February 16, 2023 20:59

I think you’re being incredibly selfish if you’d prefer no referrals on the site just because you can’t share your link in this instance. If you really feel that way I’d recommend you just ignore any thread with referral in the title, you could probably set up a rss feed to even filter anything with referral in the title.

We do ban people that break the rules, but there are ways of getting around that as well.

Olympia
Olympia (@guest_1558214)
February 16, 2023 23:12

 William Charles you and Chuck provide an unbelievable service. Thank you for all you do for your readers. Sorry some have a hard time taking a step back and seeing the big picture.

Just a thought for those who feel slighted – some other resources don’t even allow comments. So many awesome details come out through this opportunity to have dialogue with others here. Please reconsider using this feature for browbeating Will and Chuck and remember what an awesome place this is.

If people are dying to share their referrals, look up other places to do so. There are quite a few if you just take some time to search.

djfly
djfly (@guest_1558467)
February 17, 2023 11:33

 William Charles How is this incredibly selfish when I will also lose the benefit of referral myself? That’s just and fair.

People are pointing out the benefits and amazing work this site does. I agree 1000% with them. I’m all praise and gratitude for the work you do. But that doesn’t mean one can’t bring up something unfair. It’s $25 or mere 1% or just one time, the fact is that locking that thread with few referrals is unfair to many. Just bringing up other benefits and contributions of site doesn’t change that.

I know my options and can filter or ignore the threads I’d like. You asked me my opinion and I stated as I feel. If one person, website, business or charity is doing wonderful amazing work, but you don’t like one thing you notice, it’s absolutely okay to bring it up.

If managing a referral thread is actually a problem, then how can you have any new referral thread ever? Wouldn’t it have same issues and problems? Locking ONE thread is not the solution.

William Charles
Admin
February 17, 2023 21:39

> If managing a referral thread is actually a problem, then how can you have any new referral thread ever? Wouldn’t it have same issues and problems?

Yes, it does have issues and problems but at this stage we are happy to deal with them for a short period of time until people breaking the rules become the main issue.

I think at this stage we will just have to agree to disagree.

djfly
djfly (@guest_1559020)
February 18, 2023 01:57

 William Charles Sure, as I said before, your site, your rules. I was just sharing my honest opinion. Agree to disagree it is!

djfly
djfly (@guest_1559033)
February 18, 2023 03:07

 William Charles just as an fyi, the very first three post in that referral thread are by users who have only ONE post ever on this site. If that says anything.

ntn
ntn (@guest_1558198)
February 16, 2023 22:56

Nobody asked my opinion but I want to jump in here anyway 🙂

As a new-ish reader, I was grateful for the ability to use one of the links posted in that closed referral thread. Sure, it sucks that I now can’t post my own link, but the creators here allow numerous opportunities to post referrals elsewhere, in addition to maintaining a site that provides so many helpful resources for the community.

Instead of dwelling over the possibility of getting an additional 1% interest for 3 months, why not do one more easy bonus to offset your supposed loss?

BTW: 1% of $10k for 3 months yields a whopping $25.

Credit Card Offers
Credit Card Offers (@guest_1451443)
September 23, 2022 20:07

This is a good offer. With referral it would provide the highest rate for a good savings account

Chase-ing UR Points
Chase-ing UR Points (@guest_1412672)
July 21, 2022 02:28

 Chuck  William Charles

It looks like the current offer is now an extra 1% APY bump for both people. (https://www.marcus.com/us/en/savings/referrals)

The current APY is listed as 1.2%. This would make it 2.2% and then 2.3% APY (when combined with the 0.10% bump from AARP). The offer terms mention the promo period as being 7/1-9/30.

SONER SECKINER
SONER SECKINER (@guest_1268292)
October 17, 2021 19:44

When will you open referral links in the dedicated post?

Celia
Celia (@guest_1254037)
September 15, 2021 17:57

 William Charles  Chuck Looks like Marcus is doubling their rate for 3 months for referrals instead of the .2%

No end date mentioned in email.

Good things? They’re meant to be shared. With Marcus Referred, you can help your friends and family double the APY on their Online Savings Account!

Refer someone to Marcus savings and they’ll receive an Annual Percentage Yield (APY) Referral Bonus of 0.50% on an Online Savings Account for 3 months. You could receive the same Referral Bonus, too.

Shri
Shri (@guest_1254508)
September 16, 2021 16:15

Just opened this post to add a comment for the same bonus offer. The email that I got today has an end date of December 31, 2021.

JJ
JJ (@guest_1248668)
September 4, 2021 12:11

Marcus updated, As a Marcus customer, you can pay it forward and help your friends grow their savings, too. When you refer a new customer to Marcus, you both could earn a Referral Bonus: an additional 0.50% Annual Percentage Yield (APY) on your Online Savings Accounts for 3 months. PM if you need a refer

Soner
Soner (@guest_1187069)
May 6, 2021 09:13

Hi admin, can you open referral posts in the link. I need it thanks.
https://www.doctorofcredit.com/marcus-bank-referral-thread/

Trevor
Trevor (@guest_1144397)
February 13, 2021 11:18

The January 27th email I got about an approved referral said I was at 3 referrals out of 5 max for the year, but the February 10th email said I’m at 4 of the max 3. Did the limit go back down to 3 per year but they’re grandfathering?

Either way, I’m getting 0.8% for the whole year (with AARP bonus, if the rate doesn’t drop) which just means I didn’t have move funds back to Customer Bank’s lack of an interface to get their consistently more competitive rate, which is 0.75% at the moment.