Papa John’s: Free Pizza with $25 Gift Card Purchase

The Offer

Direct Link

  • Purchase a $25 e-gift card from Papa John via Cashstar and get a free single-topping pizza


The Fine Print

  • This deal is valid through 12/25/16. Free pizza can be claimed through 1/22/17.
  • Redeemable online at in the U.S. only.
  • Multiple promo codes may be redeemed in a single order.
  • May not be valid for some discounts or offers.
  • No double toppings or extra cheese.
  • Delivery fee and delivery minimum may apply. To avoid fees or order minimum, order must be placed as carryout and picked up by customer.
  • Papa John’s not responsible for lost, misplaced, or undelivered promo code emails.

Our Verdict

Pretty good deal. You can even sell the $25 gift card for up to 75% of its value, although I assume most people will do this for personal use.

It sounds to me like you can get unlimited amounts of free pizza vouchers by purchasing multiple $25 e-gift cards. Not sure if the purchases have to be split up or can be done together.

This deal is processed via Cashstar so I assume it won’t work in conjunction with the Amex Offer at Papa John’s. Readers tell us that this Amex Offer works with Cashstar too. Use a registered Amex card to stack the deal.

Another good deal at Papa John’s is to get a free pizza with the purchase of a pizza. Both of these deals stack with the Amex Offer.

Hat tip to Audrey

Leave a Reply


newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Is anybody else having trouble getting 500 MR points for Amex offer to post? I made a $14 pizza purchase and 3 separate $10 gift purchases at store on different cards. No email was received on any of the purchases nor did points post. After multiple online chats with Amex, all the points finally posted after 2 weeks.


can we purchase this with visa checkout and get 2 free pizzas with their offer as well?


There is a visa checkout offer too. Pay with visacheckout and get free large pizza with next order. Should be stackable with Amex offer at least.


surprisingly, I got “congratulation” email from Amex
although I bought PJ e-giftcards on cashstar.
There are other DPs that replicate my DP.
I think each retailer processes payment a little differently for cashstar transaction.


Groupon regulary has deals if buy $25 gc receive 2 free pizzas


Better to buy $10 gcs with Amex deals for effective min 50% off. Mmmmm pizza


Do gift cards code correctly for AMEX offers?