Subscribe
Notify of
guest

1K Comments
newest
oldest most voted

marpa
marpa (@guest_1138703)
February 3, 2021 12:25

made transfer from PNC to external account at HSBC personal. It was codified “Deposit From Pncbk Sv, Webxfr-p2p, Ypep0000, System Generated 2”
Are any of the pushes described as DDs?

WRDinc
WRDinc (@guest_1050644)
September 8, 2020 16:14

6/2: p1 & p2 opened acct w/$1 push from chase
6/22: $5099 push from chase
7/14: $5000.03 push from pnc
8/6: $5010 push from chase
9/2:$5002 push from chase
9/4: $475 2020 q2 online acquisition campaign

Ben
Ben (@guest_1088309)
November 10, 2020 19:04

When you say push from PNC, you’re talking about an ACH transfer from PNC to “your external account”?

Nazmul Mahmud
Nazmul Mahmud (@guest_1093889)
November 18, 2020 20:51

I have the same question.
Does DD mean I should do an External transfer to my HSBC account?

Milo
Milo (@guest_1097475)
November 25, 2020 10:14

OK, so first time I have posted, so my apologies if this has already been explicitly answered. But, in all fairness, I did read through the posts (well I searched them for a keyword) and could not find a direct answer to my question about the coding of the ACH transfer from PNC to HSBC.

It reads “ACH WEBSINGLE XXXXX9565 HSBCBK CK WEBXFR TRANSFER”

Does the fact that it codes as WEBSINGLE become problematic as it infers it is NOT a recurring monthly push?

Thanks to anyone, in advance, who chimes in.

Regards,

JS
JS (@guest_1049075)
September 4, 2020 22:47

I was trying to get the Discover push in during August, but it didn’t make it. I wanted to be safe as the DP on Sofi aren’t a sure thing and I didn’t see any DPs on SchoolsFirst.

6/29 Opened Account (did $500 pull)
7/15 Push from Sofi Money – $5000
7/22 Push from SchoolsFirst CU – $5000
8/12 Push from Sofi Money – $5000
8/21 Push from SchoolsFirst CU – $5000
9/02 Push from Discover – $5000
9/04 First Bonus Paid – $120

So, can anyone tell, was the bonus paid on 9/04 a result of the Discover push that just went through? Or was it more likely from one of the July pushes?

Either way, I was pretty excited to get this one. There seems to be some mixed results. Looking forward to the next 5 months.

Jatan
Jatan (@guest_1049124)
September 5, 2020 00:42
  JS

9/4 bonus is for your July DDs

credit_addiction
credit_addiction (@guest_1035649)
August 13, 2020 10:27

Updated DP:
Chase Instant Transfer don’t count as DD in HSBC.
Real time transfer from Chase to HSBC $5000 on July 21.
Code as “RTP TRANSFER from ***”
Different from previous code as “DEPOSIT FROM DISCOVER BANK-P2P” when I use Discover to get the bonus.
$50 maintenance fee post on statement on Aug 11th.
I will try Chase standard transfer next time.

Megan
Megan (@guest_1049921)
September 6, 2020 23:28

Thank you for your sacrifice in the name of science! <3

justmeha
justmeha (@guest_1069266)
October 6, 2020 22:21

so when it shows up as “DEPOSIT FROM DISCOVER BANK-P2P” it works (even though it says p2p) ?

Joe
Joe (@guest_1011070)
July 7, 2020 00:09

I chatted w/ rep after not receiving bonus for a while, evidently my Ally pushes were considered regular ACH transfers and not “direct deposits”, although the rep didn’t seem confident. She even asked me if they were direct deposits before claiming they didn’t “appear” that way. Supposedly she was going to open an inquiry. No clue why one account bonus triggered with same timeline/approach and the other didn’t.

Red Baron
Red Baron (@guest_1012307)
July 8, 2020 19:59

After waiting several months for this bonus, I had virtually the same conversation with a CSR this week. I did not bring up Ally, but indicated that the deposits from a business should have qualified. She said that the bonus should have been paid on June 6 if the deposit criteria were met. Also waiting for the outcome of an inquiry. I plead guilty to the sin of contacting the bank, but frankly this issue needs to be resolved one way or another. It really is not useful for many people to waste time, effort, and money trying to obtain a bonus that a bank will never issue.

Banking Bad
Banking Bad (@guest_1015287)
July 13, 2020 01:05

I did not have any hopes with this bank and waited for a couple of years before applying after reading all the comments and experiences but I got $750 but with split deposits each month from ally and discover and did for 4 months. I read some posts below that said they had not received after 3 monthly deposits and kept doing for another month and was told by some bank reps and after the 4th month they received the bonus. I opened at the end of Dec. and did deps from Jan through April and the bonus posted in May. Also, this is my highest bonus so far and the account opening was not hard as others pointed.

Bob
Bob (@guest_1015432)
July 13, 2020 09:04

Did you do Ally expedited push (next day deposit)? Or the 2-3 day?

Banking Bad
Banking Bad (@guest_1015736)
July 13, 2020 18:10

With Ally I have never seen or used the expedited push option – I have not paid attention – usually based on the bank that I am transferring to, ally tells the processing and deposit dates during the transaction and I think in this case they were all processed the following day but I am not sure.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1007161)
June 30, 2020 17:20

1/6/2020 – Account Application Submitted Online
1/31/2020 – Account Approved
3/12/2020 – Ally ACH Push $5001
4/14/2020 – Ally ACH Push $5001
5/18/2020 – Ally ACH Push $5001
6/25/2020 – Ally ACH Push $5001
6/30/2020 – $750 Bonus Received

ACH Pushes appeared as “DEPOSIT FROM ALLY BANK-P2P”

Thanks, DoC!

Joe
Joe (@guest_1007686)
July 1, 2020 10:18

That’s odd, I did basically the exact same thing (same app date, all ACH pushes from Ally) and still nothing =/ Did you transfer the money out after the pushes or leave it in there for a while?

Eric
Eric (@guest_1010853)
July 6, 2020 17:13

Joe – I did transfer the money out but always left about $5k in (basically transferred out once the next one was in). Did you have a deposit from Ally at least once on every statement?

Bob
Bob (@guest_1015433)
July 13, 2020 09:05

Did you do Ally expedited ACH push (next day deposit)? Or the 2-3 day?

Bob
Bob (@guest_1015445)
July 13, 2020 09:40

Did you do Expedited ACH Push (next day) or standard delivery time (2-3 day)?

Veroeah
Veroeah (@guest_1003891)
June 25, 2020 09:31

Schwab Brokerage ACH did NOT work as DP for me.

Aaron
Aaron (@guest_1134696)
January 27, 2021 14:51

Were you able to trigger your bonus? Did Schwab Brokerage come through eventually or did you use another ach / direct deposit method?

yugi
yugi (@guest_994080)
June 7, 2020 18:11

Opened 2 accounts end of December
I did 3 pushes from Chase in Jan, Feb, Mar.
In April $750 posted on both accounts.
When can I close both accounts, since I’m close to 6 months now?

vkir
vkir (@guest_1016803)
July 15, 2020 10:06

Do you ming sharing how did it code? mine is “DEPOSIT FROM JPMORGAN CHASE-EXT TRNSFR #### SYSTEM GENERATED”

yugi
yugi (@guest_1016919)
July 15, 2020 12:55

I closed the accounts, so I don’t have the info anymore. It was a slow push from Chase.

Andrew P Jones
Andrew P Jones (@guest_993693)
June 6, 2020 21:12

Does anyone know if you can use the same $5k to fund this account? As in deposit $5k and then withdraw and redeposit. I bank with Chase and SoFi. Does anyone have an opinion on which ACH transfer would best trigger the DD requirement? Thanks!

yugi
yugi (@guest_994920)
June 9, 2020 10:37

I was cycling between Chase, HSBC and Citi, and it was fine.

CtownBin
CtownBin (@guest_992736)
June 4, 2020 19:00

Successful DP:

Applied 12/25/19. Was NOT initially approved, apparently there was an ID check that required manual verification of the documents I uploaded (Driver’s license, SS card, maybe Green Card? etc) and they were really backed up.

1/16/20- APPROVED. Called in and confirmed with the rep that even though I was approved after the promotion expiry of 1/6/20, that for promotion purposes it is as if I opened in December. The account opening date for the DD timing was still 1/16/20, she said, so that I would have the same time as everyone else to set up the DD. Basically the better of both worlds, though this was only fair as the large delay was no fault of my own. I was skeptical but she was VERY certain. She also confirmed that it went by the second full month, so with a January opening I needed the $5k DD in March, April, and May.

(Note: I cannot stress enough how important it is, usually, to NOT call the bank. I only did here because of the very unusual circumstance of the large delay between application and approval which pushed me over the expiry date, and I needed to know what my story was. Also I made sure of course to only call BEFORE I ever did any DD, so that there would be no problem at all if there were human eyes on me at that point.)

3/19/20: ~$2500 from Serve
3/27/20: ~$2500 from Chase (regular transfer, NOT real-time)

4/28/20: ~$2500 from Serve
4/30/20: ~$2500 from Chase

5/19/20: ~$2500 from Serve
5/21/20: ~$2500 from Chase

5/29/20: $750 bonus posted, yay!

Main takeaway here is that that starting the DDs from the second full month after opening worked to get the bonus. From earlier data points, it seems that starting from the first month- as the terms used to state- ALSO worked to get the bonus, even for those accounts opened after the terms changed. So it looks like EITHER one worked. It’s also helpful to know that if there is a significant delay between application and approval, you will still qualify for the promotion based on when you originally applied.

Overall, this was probably the best bonus I have completed over years of doing these (thanks to Doc!). There has never been anything close to a $750 bonus without having to deposit a significant sum and maintain it for a while, and it seems that many different ACH methods worked to trigger it. Here’s hoping it returns and congrats to everyone who got it!

vkir
vkir (@guest_1017244)
July 15, 2020 22:51

CtownBin Do you mind sharing how did Chase ACH code? mine shows “DEPOSIT FROM JPMORGAN CHASE-EXT TRNSFR #### SYSTEM GENERATED”

CtownBin
CtownBin (@guest_1017283)
July 16, 2020 00:12

This is exactly how mine coded, verbatim.

vkir
vkir (@guest_1017546)
July 16, 2020 12:19

CtownBin thanks! hope it doesn’t get messed up if I linked Chase in HSBC. You can’t really tell if DD counted before the first statement closes and you find out if you got a monthly fee or not?

CtownBin
CtownBin (@guest_1017709)
July 16, 2020 16:02

There are many situations in which even a waiver a monthly fee does not guarantee you will get the bonus. Sometimes a transaction may qualify as DD for purposes of monthly fee waiver but not for bonus purposes- this has happened before with other banks.
But I can tell you that if you did a standard transfer (NOT real-time) from Chase to HSBC (not the other way around of course), this counts for bonus purposes as of May.

shelley
shelley (@guest_1519654)
December 27, 2022 00:50

what is dp meaning