Subscribe
Notify of
guest
The comment form collects your name, email and content to allow us keep track of the comments placed on the website.

77 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Kev
Kev (@guest_2099139)
July 14, 2025 17:44

Denied for too many Chex inquiries.

An
An (@guest_2099196)
July 14, 2025 19:13

What were your stats?

RM
RM (@guest_2097941)
July 12, 2025 18:08

In-branch opening DP: P2 successfully opened in branch, but got the stink eye from the banker about her (pretty modest) Chex numbers: 0/1, 1/2, 1/3, 2/6, 5/12, 6/15, 9/24. Banker went over every single Chex hit for the last 15 months, and wanted to know why P2 had opened each account and whether it was still open. Then the banker went into the back, presumably for permission from the manager to open the account. Not sure whether this was a bank policy issue or whether it was just this specific banker, but they do seem quite sensitive even in branch.

TJ
TJ (@guest_2097642)
July 12, 2025 09:05

They told me I need to unfreeze Experian for them to process my application. Not sure why they need to look at my Experian.

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2097739)
July 12, 2025 12:32
  TJ

Good news it is only a soft pull on Experian. As to why this and any other credit union that does it (which is usually a hard pull in most instances), might be to see if you’re a candidate for one of their loans or credit cards in the future.

Ever since I opened the account, I was getting emails from them daily (sometimes two or three) telling me of their special deals on credit cards and loan products. I finally unsubscribed from them and they’ve stopped for the most part so that might be why the soft pull.

An
An (@guest_2097779)
July 12, 2025 13:42

I think sometimes they use Experian for identity verification.

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2097846)
July 12, 2025 15:49
  An

Also true.

Jen
Jen (@guest_2097595)
July 12, 2025 02:16

How long does it take for the opening deposit to show up?

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2098210)
July 13, 2025 09:44

For the savings account the $10 showed up two days later but the $100 for the checking account never showed up (both were from the same bank). I inquired by chat after 5 days of it not showing up and after some back and forth she said it was never processed. I ended up transferring the $100 from my other bank myself though they offered to do it for me (didn’t quite trust them at that point).

If your deposits don’t show after a couple days, I’d contact them Jen

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2096920)
July 11, 2025 10:08

Here’s more info for those wanting to know what works for direct deposits. I tested using Chase Biz (the one with the $2.50 fee), Treasury Direct and from my Service credit union account. As you can see, both the Chase and TD deposits posted as ACH ECC PPD and as a Category: Paycheck/Salary while the Service deposit shows as ACH ECC WEB and as a Category: Transfer

Don’t know if all three would still count as a direct deposit with this credit union but I’ll be playing it safe and use either Chase Biz or Treasury Direct, especially since the bonus might not post for 60 days, if only one deposit is required, or over 90 days if the deposit must be done multiple times over the 90 days.

TYPE: Payroll ID: 32 CO: “MY NAME” ACH ECC PPD
Category: Paycheck/Salary 

APA TREAS 310 TYPE: MISC PAY ID: 51 CO: APA TREAS 310 ACH ECC PPD
Category: Paychecks/Salary

TYPE: TRANSFER ID: 52 CO: SERVICECU NAME: “My Name” ACH ECC WEB
Category: Transfer

Looney
Looney (@guest_2096985)
July 11, 2025 11:44

Thanks Shirley , good information to know.

maomaoUS
maomaoUS (@guest_2097079)
July 11, 2025 14:12

I used my US Bank Biz and just confirmed via online chat that I had completed the required tasks to earn the bonus, which is: $100 opening fund + $750+ DD. Since the bonus will arrive in 60 days, I am going to keep doing the $750 DD to avoid the monthly fee.

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2097115)
July 11, 2025 15:05

Good to hear though you do know that to avoid the $5 fee, you have to meet three of the five choices that they list, not just the direct deposit. Maybe you do already?

maomaoUS
maomaoUS (@guest_2097205)
July 11, 2025 16:40

You are right. Thanks. Guess I just have to pay it – No way to meet 3/5 requirements.

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2097249)
July 11, 2025 17:22

My plan is to hopefully get the bonus within 60 days and then close the account before too many $5 fees are taken out.

I chatted also and was told I met the requirements with the Treasury Direct deposit.

Looney
Looney (@guest_2097166)
July 11, 2025 15:59

Thanks for the tip maomaoUS on checking with chat to confirm meeting the requirements.

I chatted and she confirmed that my Chase Biz direct deposit worked though she did question if the deposit was made as a transfer from my another checking account. I said no, it was a payroll payment and she then said it works for the bonus. She also said that I’d have to meet three of the five items to avoid the monthly fee, not just a direct deposit.

Seems to be another indication that they won’t accept just a transfer from another checking account as Shirley was told but guess that is still to be determined by others.

Also seems to confirm that only one $750 direct deposit is needed, not multiples RM and Shirley

An
An (@guest_2097179)
July 11, 2025 16:11

From my understanding, these things are usually programmed to be handled automatically. Unless their system shows the rep if the conditions have been satisfied, I would take what they say with a grain of salt. It seems they were relying on what you told them about the deposit.

Looney
Looney (@guest_2097246)
July 11, 2025 17:20
  An

True, but the point was that she asked so that would seem to indicate that they are aware of the difference in the types of deposits and what works or not. Had I said it was a transfer, she might have said it wouldn’t work, that’s for someone else to find out.

Might not mean anything and the system might see transfers the same as it sees legitimate deposits, but along with how Shirley shows the three types of deposits, just another reason to not take a chance with a transfer.

YMMV

Shirley
Shirley (@guest_2097306)
July 11, 2025 17:59

Guess there would be time for someone to try different banks to see if something else works, especially if they pay out the bonus in under 60 days.

EvolveBankSucks
EvolveBankSucks (@guest_2095655)
July 9, 2025 17:36

I applied, got a message today saying that my Experian is blocked and they need to review the credit history…

TJ
TJ (@guest_2096723)
July 10, 2025 23:16

When did you apply? I still haven’t heard anything.

An
An (@guest_2095638)
July 9, 2025 17:26

Do they report to EWS?

TJ
TJ (@guest_2094960)
July 8, 2025 22:33

I threw an application in. $1010 max on credit card. We shall see if they approve of my Chex.

Lee S.
Lee S. (@guest_2097749)
July 12, 2025 12:48
  TJ

Hi TJ,
Can you confirm your $1010 credit card funding was accepted for your new acct opening and that it has posted? TIA

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_2099767)
July 15, 2025 13:13
  TJ

Did your credit card code as a purchase or cash advance, do you know?

RM
RM (@guest_2094810)
July 8, 2025 18:49

For what it’s worth, a phone CSR I spoke to today said that only one $750 DD was required, directly contradicting the CSR Shirley spoke to. https://www.doctorofcredit.com/ca-only-credit-union-of-southern-california-500-checking-bonus/#comment-2092821

RM
RM (@guest_2094482)
July 8, 2025 12:24

Update on my referral terms post: https://www.doctorofcredit.com/ca-only-credit-union-of-southern-california-500-checking-bonus/#comment-2092815

Phone CSR claimed that referral offer is $50 for the referrer and $500 for the referee. https://www.cusocal.org/about-us/membership/care-to-share/ I also think that this is the most plausible reading of the terms, although the language is self-contradictory — so take it for what it’s worth.