Subscribe
Notify of
guest

12 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Frewayfighter
Frewayfighter (@guest_911860)
February 17, 2020 20:47

Did anyone get bonuses from November offer yet?

AlarmingConsequence
AlarmingConsequence (@guest_677596)
November 23, 2018 19:20

There are no branches in northern California.
https://www.homestreet.com/locations

keiwei
keiwei (@guest_676380)
November 21, 2018 16:35

Beware, HomeStreet is notorious for delaying the mailing of your debit card. So if you set up direct deposit it might take you a while to be able to get your money back out should you need it.

Matt P
Matt P (@guest_676372)
November 21, 2018 16:13

I guess I got lucky considering all the other dps. I didn’t get charged the fee since I put the $2500 early enough and they gave me the $300 bonus after 1 $1000 DD from my work. That was for the promo ending in August. This one is pretty awful.

Superchurn
Superchurn (@guest_676340)
November 21, 2018 15:09

So, lets dissect this a little bit.

To keep the account fee free, you need to keep $2500 in for 365 days. That’s an opportunity cost of $125 if you put that $2500 into Consumer’s CU at 5% for that year instead. So that reduces the effective bonus to $175.

If you opt to pay the $10 fee for a year, that’s $120, reducing your bonus to $180, slightly better.

Their website also sucks ass.

So we’re looking at a crappy, inquiry-sensitive bank with awful customer service, a bad website, and a hostile view of bonuses…a bank that shuts down people post-account opening. For $180?

No thanks.

Soju
Soju (@guest_676325)
November 21, 2018 14:33

One tip. Unless you open in branch, I don’t know how you will hit the $2500 minimum to not be charged a fee. Put at least $2510 in there for the first month and be prepared to get charged the $10. You can call and get that reversed. However, if the fee causes you to dip below 2500 again, you’ll get charged $10 the next month. It was nil impossible (not to mention not worth the time/effort) to get the second $10 fee reimbursed even though it was their fault.

Superchurn
Superchurn (@guest_676337)
November 21, 2018 15:05

yeah, i believe this 100%. they’re a shithole bank. the only reason I keep them around is cause they let me deposit money orders remotely

Wade
Wade (@guest_676314)
November 21, 2018 13:33

Is it possible to open the account, switch to basic no-fee version after bonus arrive to keep it for one year with less pain?

AlarmingConsequence
AlarmingConsequence (@guest_676818)
November 22, 2018 11:21

I’m curious about a downgrade option too!

ccc
ccc (@guest_676311)
November 21, 2018 13:31

Direct deposit $5,000+, with monthly fee, plus must stay open for a total of 365 days?

LOL. Not worth it.

anthonyjh21
anthonyjh21 (@guest_676297)
November 21, 2018 12:54

This is a really touchy bank and as you said is prone to hovering over your account and needing to complete annoying calls. To close the account it has to be a snail mail letter. Customer service is hit and miss, sometimes being unbelievably rude. Overall, definitely not a smooth bonus hunting opportunity.

At any rate, I’d definitely pass on this unless you’re willing to accept a CITI/HSBC flavor with a small town feel to it.

Jeff G
Jeff G (@guest_676295)
November 21, 2018 12:53

I’m one of those that have been approved (twice! shame on me) and then shut down. I’m not going to be seduced by you anymore, HomeStreet!