Subscribe
Notify of
guest

3.4K Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Avi
Avi (@guest_1991193)
January 24, 2025 17:12

Anyone who called in after 10/31 for the $100 and received the GC?
I talked to a relationship banker on 12/17. When I chatted with them today about the status of my gift card, CSR told me that the promotion was only available from 9/1 to 10/31

Tom MacDonald
Tom MacDonald (@guest_1991352)
January 24, 2025 22:06

I called and spoke with a banker 11-4. Opened my account in October and took a screenshot of the terms Here are the terms:

Earn a $100 digital gift card when you:

  1. open a personal checking account online at bmo.com/fallbonus, and

2. meet with a BMO Banker within 90 days of account opening, in-branch or over the phone to discuss financial priorities and what you want and need from your banking. The personal checking account must be open at the time of the conversation.
During the conversation, the BMO Banker will use the myFinancial Compass guide to understand your …….You must supply a valid email address and the BMO Banker must complete the myFinancial Compass guide; these items will be documented by the banker…… You do not need to meet the up to $500 personal checking cash bonus offer requirements to earn the $100 digital gift card.
Between 1 and 60 days after you complete the conversation, you will be sent an email from [email protected] with instructions on how to select one of three $100 digital gift cards…….Once you choose your gift card, you will receive another email from [email protected] with instructions on how to download the gift card. Download it within 30 days. Once downloaded they do not expire……value equals $100 and can be used online or in store. …..
must not have received $100 gift card from financial compass in the last 12 months to qualify…….

Tom MacDonald
Tom MacDonald (@guest_1990174)
January 23, 2025 04:00

Having the craziest full moon experience ever with BMO SM. I called 9-2023 and closed my account. Opened 10-2024 and did dd from work that totaled over $7500 within 90 days. Spoke with a banker in November for the $100. I don’t have the $500 or $100 bonus so I send a SM to ask about it. They reply I don’t qualify because I had a bus. acct. in 2024 so I tell them that’s not in the terms. They reply again that I don’t qualify because I closed my personal account 10-2023. I tell them no I closed it 9-2023 with a phone call and told them who I spoke with and at the exact time EST. Then they ignore me and close the ticket.
I SM them again and ask about it. They reply that I don’t qualify for the $500 for the same reasons as above and that I need to call the branch I spoke with about the $100. I reply with my facts about the last personal checking closing date and ask how do I know which branch to call? I only have the email address and phone number of the banker I spoke with and she is not responding to my emails or answering her direct line!!!
This is getting frustrating ……… The only thing I can imagine here is that when I called to close my account 9-2023 that they did NOT close it and they just let it go into 10-2023 with the zero balance to close automatically. If that is what has happened then that’s not my fault and I wonder if I am just out this bonus, or maybe I would have better luck calling someone?

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 23, 2025 04:09

I’d be curious to know what the closure date of the account that shows on your EWS report. Not sure it would help your case though. Takes a week or two to get the report so it won’t be quick though.

Surprised they aren’t able to tell you “your branch”. I know Fifth Third and Regions will list it on the monthly statements. You could do your own research and pick the closest one as the crow flies…. See what they say when you call.

I’d say you are going to end up filing a CFPB.

vc
vc (@guest_1990205)
January 23, 2025 07:31

I would get everything in writing. IME, banks will tell you when your acct will be closed after they submit the request. If you recall that info, I’d continue fighting it w them first, and then file a CFPB. They left my biz acct open for at least a month after I closed it. So, you’re probably right about what happened w the closure. You may want to try contacting via chat and asking to tt a supervisor to find out if they can confirm when you called to close, and when they closed it. Before letting them know your issue, ask how long it normally takes to close a ck acct.

BMOBonusMoney
BMOBonusMoney (@guest_1990095)
January 22, 2025 22:25

I’m going to do a Wise transfer and schedule it for two days instead of instantly.  Should this trigger the DD?

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_1989751)
January 22, 2025 12:16

Have not recieved bonus yet, but here is my data on ACH transfers on how things code:
Chase: PPD JPMorgan Chase Ext Trnsfr
US Bank instant: RTP CREDIT [NAME] ($X)
US Bank normal: WEB US BANK TRANSFER TRANSFER ($X)
Citibank: WEB IIT CITIBANK CITIXFR ($X)
Wells Fargo: WEB WELLS FARGO IFI
Charles Schwab: PPD SCHWAB BROKERAGE MONEYLINK
Fidelity: PPD FID BKG SVC LLC MONEYLINE

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 22, 2025 12:29

Just because Schwab and Fidelity post as PPD doesn’t mean they work. I can call it now… you will not be getting the bonus if this is what you were relying on. Alexia

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_1989764)
January 22, 2025 12:38

Gotcha, I hear you. Is there data to support this?
And what about Chase, which also coded as PPD?
Maybe I’ll try Treasury Direct or Wise. (both methods new to me, so I will need to do some research).

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 22, 2025 13:49

Data? I can give you about three year old data when my P2 tried Serve, PPD, did not work.

Here is a current Schwab DP: https://www.doctorofcredit.com/il-wi-mn-in-az-fl-ks-mo-bmo-harris-350-checking-300-savings-bonus/#comment-1980619

Chase BIZ will show up as PPD and work as a DD, yes, but not Chase personal.

Wise sometimes shows as RTP and that would very likely not work. Alexia

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_1989807)
January 22, 2025 14:00

Thank you. I might abandon this. Don’t feel like opening up a Wise account, and while I do have TD already, I’m having trouble navigating the archaic website and figuring out how to send money to a bank, even though I have the bank linked already.

Thank you again for the heads up, very much appreciated.

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 22, 2025 14:06

You would either need to buy a 4-week T-bill, which takes about 5 weeks start to finish… or, fund the Certificate of Indebtedness for a full week, and then move funds to BMO.

I am sure there are YouTube videos or tutorials online… it would be a shame to give up, but you do you.

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_1989820)
January 22, 2025 14:25

Ah that makes sense. Thank you for the tip on TD. Will look into it. Basically buy something on TD, and then when it matures, “redeem” it into BMO. Will look up youtube.

I was stuck in the mindset if moving money into TD and then moving money back out via ACH. Need the intermediate step of buying something on TD. Will also look into the C of I.

Thank you, again.

JD
JD (@guest_1989825)
January 22, 2025 14:35

You fund your C of I from a linked bank. After a week or so, you’re free to redeem those funds to any other linked bank. No need for youtube, lmao.

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 22, 2025 14:54
  JD

Some people like to “SEE” how it’s done… with their “archaic website”.

You left out several details, like specifically if trying to pull more than $1,000… you have to do multiple deposits. Same day is fine.

JD
JD (@guest_1989849)
January 22, 2025 15:04

Point taken, but any reference to Youtube which probably shovels views to that lady with questionable opinions is a no go on my part.

Brian R
Brian R (@guest_1989835)
January 22, 2025 14:47

Once you’re signed in at Treasury Direct click on the Buy Direct tab at the top of the page, next to the My Account tab.
Then you’ll see a series of choices, near the bottom of the page will be “C of I – A non-interest bearing security which can be used to fund TreasuryDirect purchases”, click on this and click submit.
Then enter the amount you want to purchase (max $1,000, but you can do more than one purchase per day).
If you have your bank info already entered in then click on the account you wish to use to purchase,
You can choose a single purchase or schedule purchases (I just do singles), then click submit again.
You get one more screen that tells you that your C of I funds need to stay in for a minimum of five days before you can move them (to T Bills, or in your case into a new bank account), click submit again, then one more screen shows all the details of the purchase, click submit again.
You can immediately repeat the purchase if you wish.
If you click on the Current Holdings tab you can see your C of I holdings and when the money is available for redemption to your BMO account, which you set up while you’re waiting the five days. Once it’s settled you can send it out all out once or in increments.
If you try to move the money out early your account will get shut down and you’ll have to get a form signed and notarized to open it back up (ask me how I know).

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_1989846)
January 22, 2025 15:00

Amazing directions. Each screen was exactly how you described. I did 5 in a row. Will wait 5 (maybe 6 to be sure, considering your unfortunate experience) days before transferring out.

I’m surprised they let you attempt to try to move the money out. most banks would just mark the funds on hold, and then release them once they are available, so the user is unable to even attempt to move the funds. But then again, TD is not a bank, I suppose.

Interesting note: “The option to fund your C of I from payroll or ACH credit will be discontinued on January 31, 2025″
https://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/help/treasurydirect-help/user-guide/151-160/#152

Seems I will be able to do this just under the wire.

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 22, 2025 15:05

Some people preferred to push funds to the C of I to decrease the wait/holding period. That is the functionality that is going away. The ACH transfer function you did is not.

Only select banks were able to be linked that anyway, so it’s not a big loss (at least not to me). And, I don’t think you cannot miss something you did not use.

Alexia
Alexia (@guest_1989915)
January 22, 2025 16:46

Ah I see the specific language now. “The option to fund… from…” is an ACH push from the bank.

ACH pull from TD is not going away.

Thank you for the clarification. Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek

Sher
Sher (@guest_1989880)
January 22, 2025 15:46

Am I able to do this with a brand new TD account (opened today)? Or should I wait until it’s a bit older? Don’t want to risk a lock down.

Josh
Josh (@guest_1991200)
January 24, 2025 17:24

Hey Gadget!

Is there a difference between a T-Bill vs COI in terms of successfully triggering direct deposit requirements?

Or are they both recognized the same way by banks?

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 24, 2025 17:41

I don’t think there would be a difference. Both are coming from the same entity – the Treasury Dept. However, we can only see so much data on our online banking screen or bank statement.

There are not enough DP’s out there to compare where they state if they used T-bill or C of I.

Treasury Direct rarely fails. I heard Fairwinds, SoFi, and now one person said First Tech failed, but that last one was only after they “called the bank”. Josh  

Churn
Churn (@guest_1989303)
January 21, 2025 15:45

If you use Wise, is it coding as RTP or PPD? Is there a way to schedule it to post to an account in 1 or two days?

Royse
Royse (@guest_1989347)
January 21, 2025 16:52

It was PPD , if you You choose to pay someone, if to yourself, it will be RTP

BmoHarris
BmoHarris (@guest_1989562)
January 21, 2025 23:26

Thanks for the reply. If I send an instant payment from Wise to BMO Harris, will it code as PPD?

BMOBonusMoney
BMOBonusMoney (@guest_1990099)
January 22, 2025 22:39

Should I put that the account is not myself?

An
An (@guest_1989023)
January 21, 2025 03:58

I wonder if we can downgrade (and upgrade back?) for the current offers to avoid the $25 fee. I can’t find terms about the account type after opening.

Rostyslav Tymoshenko
Rostyslav Tymoshenko (@guest_1989001)
January 21, 2025 00:41

10\12\24 open
10\30\24 Wise DD 100$
10\30\24 Wise DD 4000$
11\06\24 Wise DD 3500$
01\21\24 Bonus 500$ in Pending
01\21\24 Gift Card in Pending
I couldn’t open it online, so I opened it at the branch. They didn’t send me a card for $100 until I started writing to support. They replied that I didn’t meet the conditions. I explained the situation, that the website sent me to the branch for verification and whether they could review the decision. After that they sent me a gift

BmoHarris
BmoHarris (@guest_1989919)
January 22, 2025 16:51

Did you schedule the Wise transfer 1-2 days in advance or was it an instant payment?

vic torr
vic torr (@guest_1987112)
January 17, 2025 08:56

Is the One-time refund of monthly fee/service charge once per customer/SSN? i.e. I requested this before and closed the account, will I get another chance if opening a new account later and get hit with the fee again?

Any DP is appreciated.

Lefty
Lefty (@guest_1987113)
January 17, 2025 09:01

Yes if they provide the waiver it’s a one-time event and per account. I’ve churned BMO multiple times and never had an issue receiving the waiver with each new account.

Daniel
Daniel (@guest_1987040)
January 17, 2025 03:09

There is a $600 bonus for opening BMO relationship checking: https://bmo.com/600winterbonus
Requirements are:

  1. Open a new BMO Relationship Checking account; and
  2. Have a cumulative total of $10,000 in qualifying direct deposits within 90 days of account opening; and
  3. The primary account holder must reside in California, Colorado, or Nevada at the time of account opening.

Offer ends on Feb 3rd, 2025.

mangorunner
mangorunner (@guest_1987474)
January 17, 2025 17:38

I don’t live in one of the three qualifying states.
For me, the link forwards to a $500 bonus offer:
“Open a BMO Relationship Checking account and earn a $500 cash bonus!”
Requires $7,500 in qualifying direct deposits within 90 days.
Offer ends on Feb 3rd, 2025.

If there’s no way to get the $600 offer, I’ll do the $500. I might like the terms better, anyway. Thanks, Daniel!

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 17, 2025 17:51

Interesting. Mine seems to show the $600… flash the $500… then continues to the $600, which I cannot do because I am also not in those states.

Playing around, I can see the $500 offer at: https://www.bmo.com/en-us/main/personal/checking-accounts/relationship-bonus/

BUT… that offer requires a mailer promo code.

1 To take advantage of the new personal checking account cash bonus offer, you must open your account between November 1, 2024 and February 3, 2025, and use the promo code found in the mailer. “

Does your $500 page show that line at the top of the fine print? mangorunner

If not, I assume your URL shows a giant code? Like: /?COID=BMOP- etc.

Sher
Sher (@guest_1987540)
January 17, 2025 19:55

I played around with the link as well and got the $500 offer. I saw the same verbiage you did but also saw this at the bottom:

“If you apply for a checking account at a branch or on the phone, you must provide the promo code to a banker. To apply for a checking account online, visit BMO.com/500winterbonus and select “OPEN IN MINUTES”. We will automatically apply the promo code for you.”

When I click on the link it did state that the code has been applied.
Do you think that means it will work without needing a mailer?

mangorunner
mangorunner (@guest_1987975)
January 18, 2025 20:11

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗, I was in dangerous territory using my browser with an ad-blocker. When I changed to my vanilla browser and reopened the $600 link, I saw what you reported: the $600… flash the $500… then continues to the $600.

Going back to my browser with the ad-blocker, yes my $500 page does have the same fine print and shows that it requires a promo code from a mailer.

I read the other comments from you, Sher and FRD. I guess it’s now time to mull things over and decide if it’s worth the risk. I have never done the BMO bonus – this would be my first churn.

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 17, 2025 20:25

Not sure where Sher’s comment went, but yeah, looks like $500 promo page works and would not need a mailer. Sher

https://BMO.com/500winterbonus

On the application, if you scroll down, you can see the promo code is applied and has a green checkmark.

Promo code: BMOP-09144B-CHKRCDM

Looks like a winner to me.

 William Charles If you run a new page, can you update the name of the bank? They have been BMO Bank for like 2 years not. Harris is no more.

FRD
FRD (@guest_1987618)
January 18, 2025 01:38

I’m not eligible, but I’ll confirm the https://BMO.com/500winterbonus link works for me, and generates a link after you visit that site with the same promo code BMOP-09144B-CHKRCDM in the URL, and that promo code auto-populates at the bottom of the application page. I’m curious if the promotion is somehow still targeted since it says you would have received a mailer.

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 18, 2025 18:50

Right. It’s still risky to use the link because of the mailer mentioned. I was considering using it, but not sure. I think the system having validated the code would work, but there is always a chance they cross-reference later to their mailers. Hmmm…. FRD

It would be a long 3 month waiting period for that bonus to not post, and then another 12 month waiting period to try again.

Geoff
Geoff (@guest_1990521)
January 23, 2025 15:52

There’s not even an option to edit or change promo code. I think promo code on nailer is just auto-filled. Think it would work!

Knight
Knight (@guest_1985305)
January 14, 2025 22:09

Anyone else get declined?

Alex
Alex (@guest_1985649)
January 15, 2025 11:19

Yup, just tried and was declined.

Jeff
Jeff (@guest_1988138)
January 19, 2025 08:53

Yes

Knight
Knight (@guest_1988784)
January 20, 2025 15:14

Just tried it again on mobile and it was fine. Tried it on mobile for my partner and was declined

Gadget 🕵️‍♂️ Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
January 20, 2025 15:28

If you tried via the same device, could be the issue. Use their device. Knight