Subscribe
Notify of
guest

36 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Pedro Diaz
Pedro Diaz (@guest_1050810)
September 8, 2020 21:38

It’s a ripoff cause you have to spend 5000 to get back 250. After membership fee minus the up to 100 cash back because you didn’t reach the 5000 annually spending you lose 20 annually

Gadget
Gadget (@guest_702584)
January 8, 2019 16:05

 William Charles Am I blind? Because I am not seeing the must use card by 12/31 language.

The deal is not for me as I hate debit cards, but seems decent for someone who needs to spend $5k on some merch or services they know they won’t return/dispute.

Chuck
Editor
Chuck(@chucksithe)
January 8, 2019 16:28

Offer has been extended through January, so the 12/31 language was apparently dropped in the update. Updated the post now.

Ivn
Ivn (@guest_712572)
January 27, 2019 04:40

 William Charles  Chuck it seems to only have the 5% back and not the $100 bonus?

Chuck
Editor
Chuck(@chucksithe)
January 27, 2019 16:32

Looks like they pulled the $100 bonus now.

Lily
Lily (@guest_693622)
December 19, 2018 17:42

I use this card to pay my rent for about 5000, but I only saw 100 cash back. Also, I saw 100 is the maximum cash back annually on the app. Does anyone have the same problem?

Roy
Roy (@guest_688187)
December 9, 2018 23:25

Does anyone else having any issues linking Green Dot so they can push money to it? I just tried PNC and Cash App and both said the routing number said is invalid.

iks
iks (@guest_712113)
January 25, 2019 20:32

venmo?

Steven
Steven (@guest_687178)
December 7, 2018 15:20

Best case scenario is for somebody who has a major qualifying purchase around November 2019. Works out to max of $220 net cash back on $5,000:

Dec 2018: open card, pay activation fee? Deposit about $140, pay deposit fee?

Jan 2019- Oct 2019: reload Amazon .50 each month once, pay the 9.95 monthly fee each month to maintain good standing.

Nov 2019: Deposit $5,000, pay deposit fee?
Then make 2 Separate daily 2,500 charges at Home Depot for qualifying purchase items (do appliances count?), since they have a $3,000 daily limit.

Dec 2019: redeem $250 cash back on the $5,000 Home Depot qualifying purchases.

Redeem $100 sign on “bonus”, or file CFPB complaint.

Jan 2020: drain all balances, pay final 9.95 monthly fee, close account.

This “deal” is only worthwhile for somebody with a known $5000 qualifying purchase that’s taking place in November 2019.

Steven
Steven (@guest_686982)
December 7, 2018 10:15

Everybody: please read Green Dot’s entire terms and conditions, especially pay close attention to their fees and cash back section before jumping into this one. Seems like a highly restrictive prepaid debit card (Similar to Mango), many many fees.

Consider the opportunity cost of leaving your direct deposit balance sitting there not earning interest, but rather paying Green Dot many many fees.

Definitely figure out ahead of time what a “qualifying purchase” is.

Dylan
Dylan (@guest_686888)
December 7, 2018 03:47

There actually might be a way to avoid the monthly fee.

This is a prepaid card, and all prepaid accounts are unique in that the cannot be overdrafted. Meaning if they try to bill you a 9.95 fee when your account balance is zero, then they wont have anything to bill you and your account is free for the month. This is how i keep my amex serve cards fee free. I keep the balance at zero at all times so serve cannot assess a fee.

The big question here is does the balance have to be positive at the time of awarding the $100, or does it have to be positive the ENTIRE 12 months? The former situation means you can get away without paying monthly fees by keeping your account at zero as much as possible. The latter situation means you have to pay fees.

Edit: yes, it looks like this will work as per the terms!

“and must have a positive balance as of 12/31/19”

As in as long as your account has a positive balance before then, you only have to pay a single monthly fee in december!

This changes things drastically. I will be trying out.

 William Charles update your post to include this. It could be valuble.

John
John (@guest_687483)
December 8, 2018 01:09

You’d have to pay all those monthly fees to bring your account back up to positive.

Dylan
Dylan (@guest_686882)
December 7, 2018 03:34

Your first year cash back rate jumps to 4.6% after maxing this out and factoring in the $100 bonus.

Your true ongoing cash back rate is 2.6% after factoring in the monthly account fees AND assuming you max out this.

You must spend more than $3980 per year on this card to come out on top compared to something like the citi doublecash.

In other words, this is worth it the first year but not after that.

Do you have to run your transaction as credit or do you still get 5 back if you use your PIN? Hmm.

CLH Comment
CLH Comment (@guest_686744)
December 6, 2018 23:32

So once you’re through the first year you can redeem all cashback anytime correct?

Keep 13-14 Months.

$500 in Cashback ($250 for each year.)
+$100 bonus. Not horrible considering this doesn’t report to your credit.
-$140 in monthly fees.
-$110 in Liquidation fees

=$350 Profit.

Not bad since it doesn’t hit your credit, but with the MS sensitivity, I doubt you could run 5K in the last 2 months. Might have to keep for 15-16 months. With the 5% on all purchases it doesn’t really make sense to use for MS at all.

Sreven
Sreven (@guest_686971)
December 7, 2018 09:55

Careful, please read their terms and conditions. It is 5% cash back ONLY on “qualifying purchase” , which is not clearly defined. They do say online bill payments are not qualifying purchases.

Anthony
Anthony (@guest_687168)
December 7, 2018 14:52

Accrued Cash back can only be redeemed once per year at the end of each reward year. So you’re paying $120 in fees each year in advance before you can redeem the once a year redemption. So no, they don’t allow you to redeem the 2nd year cash back until you’ve prepaid another $120 monthly fees.

DrBooyah
DrBooyah (@guest_686510)
December 6, 2018 19:19

Can you deposit MOs into a GreenDot account?