Recap: AmEx Not Honoring Bonus, Data Breaches & More

 

Deals starting/expiring at the end of today or starting today (view the full deal calendar here):

Deals starting/expiring at end of tomorrow:

Popular posts from yesterday:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

29 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

BlissfulApathy
BlissfulApathy (@guest_986571)
May 25, 2020 23:10

Yet another reason why government needs to scrap the bidding process and switch to open-source/collaboratively-developed software dev. Just look at what happened with the Iowa Democratic primary.

Of course we all know why they don’t…money. Someone needs a kickback.

JB SanDiego
JB SanDiego (@guest_986309)
May 25, 2020 14:18

I have been signing up for all kinds of Amx cards for the last 3 years, when I first started collecting miles/points and Amx has always come through honoring MRs as stated. Whether through sign up links with written statements or verbal confirmation. I have always found this to be so phenomenal on Amx part, to say the least.

Having witness this with my own eyes, I take stories like this (Amx not honoring welcome bonus or any kind of MRs, for that matter), with a grain of salt. These stories are vague and always missing something (gives that impression, anyway).

SamL
SamL (@guest_986664)
May 26, 2020 02:16

I doubt your impressions are accurate. I’d bet that AmEx RAT’s zealous dragnet is causing a lot of innocent customers (and honest rule following CC gamers) to be denied earned payout and/or to get clawed back. I really don’t trust AmEx at this point. At this point there is a very real risk that they could approve you for a card, take your hefty AF, give you no SUB after required spend and deny any other card benefits, all on some concocted grounds.

JB SanDiego
JB SanDiego (@guest_987573)
May 27, 2020 17:55

Just be straight with Amx and Amx will be straight with you. Besides, Amx has, for the most part, closed all loopholes. Yes, there may be a loophole, but I wouldn’t mess with it. If you have been following DoC, I am sure you tread water carefully with Amx?

Also, I have witnessed the RAT (not fun at all is an understatement!) and yet, I have not been denied of sign up bonuses or retention offers (voice only), after my RAT incident.

anthonyjh21
anthonyjh21 (@guest_987549)
May 27, 2020 17:15

Been pretty well established this isn’t the same Amex of 3 years ago.

JB SanDiego
JB SanDiego (@guest_987576)
May 27, 2020 17:57

My experience with Amx has been most recently in the past few weeks as well as 3 years ago and everything in between.

jaesungmixberry
jaesungmixberry (@guest_989037)
May 29, 2020 21:07

Hey JB SanDiego,

I am the reddit post OP here. Completely understand where you are coming from, I’d honestly find stories like mine somewhat unbelievable too, until I bumped into situation… I recently just updated the post with some disclaimer.

Actually, yesterday, I utilized my connection and had someone looked at my case, what they found still contradicts with my account history. Thus I will update on my post once I hear back.

Matt S.
Matt S. (@guest_986272)
May 25, 2020 12:54

I’ve never been denied a SUB from AMEX, but I’m 0-2 on referral bonuses so I gave up on doing that. In both cases I had screenshots and emails from the recipient of my referral offers but after investigating AMEX claimed that the applicant didn’t use my referral link to apply. I know that’s false but nothing I could do to prove it.

Matthew
Matthew (@guest_986389)
May 25, 2020 17:52

I got all my referral (~10). Never got any problem.

AA
AA (@guest_986271)
May 25, 2020 12:51

I’m not sure what happened to earlier comment. Anyway, the weasel message is actually one of the stock error messages available in the Asterisk based phone system that Citi uses.

P
P (@guest_986265)
May 25, 2020 12:34

I had the same experience with a Hilton upgrade last year. No pop up no lifetime language and they denied upgrade bonus. I haven’t upgraded a Hilton card since even when upgrade offer keeps showing up in account or sent via email.

anthonyjh21
anthonyjh21 (@guest_987550)
May 27, 2020 17:17
  P

Same thing happened to me last year with BC > BCP upgrade. It was in my amex offers and yet for whatever reason didn’t pay out.

James
James (@guest_986257)
May 25, 2020 12:10

I had a very different (and surprisingly pleasant) experience with Amex recently. Tried to apply for Marriott Brilliant and received the dreaded pop up. Called Amex and complained, as I had also received the pop up on the $0 AF Hilton Aspire posted on DOC last November-ish. Rep said he would file a complaint on my behalf. One week later when applying I miracuously got no pop up and my 100k bonus posted last week.

Kevin
Kevin (@guest_986255)
May 25, 2020 12:03

Reading deeper into the reddit post he closed an AU card immediately on the newly approved account. To me that’s almost certainly the issue here.

jaesungmixberry
jaesungmixberry (@guest_986378)
May 25, 2020 17:06

hey Kevin, I’m the OP for the reddit post. I initially thought that was the case. Nevertheless, every rep, including a senior supervisor, that helped me opened investigation said it will not affect my SUB. In fact, they note that issue down for all 4 investigations. So if anything, either the backend team missed it 3 times and might miss it again for the 4th time, or the reason lies somewhere else.

George
George (@guest_986237)
May 25, 2020 11:02

Amazing the different between Amex and Chase. If Chase makes a mistake they eat it and they set up their systems to prevent gaming. Amex approves accounts but leaves their system ripe for abuse, perceived or real, and then denies bonuses or claws them back. End results are much steeper losses for Amex, resources to staff a RAT, probably weakened morale from CSRs, and a few angry customers they may have wanted to retain.

tribesman55
tribesman55 (@guest_986250)
May 25, 2020 11:54

Amex is just terrible in general now.

jkk
jkk (@guest_986236)
May 25, 2020 11:01

What happens with the pop-up if you have pop-ups blocked?

John
John (@guest_986238)
May 25, 2020 11:04

It’s not a browser pop-up, won’t get blocked by a pop-up blocker.