Subscribe
Notify of
guest

9 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Theory
Theory (@guest_434580)
July 6, 2017 14:55

I am in the process of doing this one – opened the account around 20 May, employer direct deposit of $25 on 1 June, bonus has not yet posted. I was told after the bonus posts, that I could downgrade my Preferred account to an Essential account to avoid the monthly fee without a direct deposit (but you need to go in-branch and fill out a form to do this). I was told there also is an inactivity fee if there is nothing going on for six months, so you’ll want to close the account shortly after open date + six months to avoid the bonus clawback and any inactivity fees.

No credit card funding. Not Chex Sensitive. I don’t know how to determine whether it was a hard or soft pull.

(Also you get to create a debit card with whatever goofy image you want! That was fun, at least.)

Theory
Theory (@guest_434833)
July 6, 2017 20:44

24 Chex inquiries in the last six months, and this was #25 – so they did check Chex, but I have no negative marks, so I assume they don’t care about many inquiries.

No hard pulls on Transunion or Equifax. FCS failed to work (tried signing up twice) and phone support was no help, so I don’t know about that one.

Theory
Theory (@guest_442030)
July 18, 2017 20:06

I’ve been in contact with the bank this week because the bonus did not post. I was told that my account would not qualify for the bonus because DDing a “portion of my paycheck” does not count as a “qualifying deposit”, and was requested a copy of my pay stub in order to verify that my deposits were my “full paycheck”.

I’ve maintained in my responses that the fine print of the bonus says nothing about this, and am still waiting on further response. I may switch my DD to deposit the full amount on the next paycheck, but I might also file my first CFPB complaint and see how that route goes.

It seems like I’ve run into this kind of thing with smaller banks more frequently, where I think this bonus is a manual process in their systems. So any behavior that looks like it’s not expected bank activity draws scrutiny.

Theory
Theory (@guest_446679)
July 25, 2017 21:30

To finish this one up: after a bit of back and forth over email, I was given the bonus without having to make additional direct deposits or provide my pay stub. Credit posted to my account yesterday.

Relevant part of the rep’s email:

“The disclosure states you need to make a direct deposit of your paycheck, pension, or government benefits(such as social security). You are correct it does not say portion, because a portion does not meet the criteria of the bonus payout. The definition of paycheck is a check for salary and wages made out to the employee. Because the Banker did not cover this with you at account opening I will credit you the $120.00.”

Conclusion: I would not do this one again. It’s too small of a bonus to justify the amount of time I spent on it, and the fact that it’s a manual process probably means I’d have to follow up manually even if I did deposit my entire paycheck.

Theory
Theory (@guest_529615)
December 3, 2017 17:08

To wrap this one up, I closed this in branch last week with no issues and it took less than 5 minutes. Also I finally got the Experian credit site to work and can confirm there were no hard pulls there, either. And lastly, I can confirm this deal is still ongoing (there were signs in the branch).