Posted by Chuck on August 18, 2015
Checking Accounts

Published on August 18th, 2015 | by Chuck

187

Guide to 5% Interest Prepaid-Savings Accounts

[Updated 9/4/15]

List of Available Options

We’ve written numerous posts about various high-interest checking or savings accounts. Many of these are actually prepaid cards which come with the benefit of an attached savings account with high-yield interest. Typically, you get an interest rate of 5% on balances of up to $5000.

There are currently nine accounts available which offer 5+% interest on balances of $5000:

Update 5/31/16: Netspend, Brinks, Western Union, Ace Elite, Control, H-E-B, and probably Paypal are lowering the 5% rate to just $1,000, effective July 1, 2016.

Other options, not as rosy:

Card Brands and Administration

There are actually two or three separate entities involved in each of these cards:

  1. There’s the front end of the card which is run by the names mentioned above (Brinks, Paypal, Control, etc.).
  2. There’s the back end of the account which is the bank who is holding the FDIC-insured accounts.
  3. Most of the above cards have a third party – confusingly Netspend – administering all of the details of the card, including customer service, programs, etc.

Let’s go through the cards and break them down as follows:

  • Netspend administers their own card and has MetaBank as the backer of the card.
  • Ace, Control, Purpose, and Western Union have Netspend as the administer of the card and Metabank as the backer of the card.
  • Brinks and H-E-B have Netspend as their administer and BofI Federal as the backer of the card. (H-E-B actually appears as part of the Netspend website itself.)
  • Paypal, Vision, and Momentum have Netspend as their administer and Bancorp as their backer.
  • Mango administers their own card and has Sunrise Banks as the backer on the accounts. (This card is unrelated to Netspend.)
  • Insightcards is part of the GreenDot system and is backed by Axiom Bank of Florida. (This card is unrelated to Netspend.)

Multiple Accounts

In order to maximize the high-interest savings, one would have to open multiple accounts since each of these accounts only gets the 5% rate on a maximum of $5,000.

Although many of these cards are issued by the same companies/backers, it’s possible to get multiples of these cards and maintain a 5+% interest rate on multiple sums of $5000.

You can use the same email address for all accounts, but each one needs a unique username.

How many can you have?

First we need to break down this issue by card issuer; most of these cards are part of the Netspend system while Mango and Insight Card are entirely separate.

You can obviously have one Mango, one Insight, and one Netspend card.

Mango: you may even be able to have multiples of those cards.

Netspend: It’s possible to have multiples of these cards. Some mention that it may even be possible to have multiples of the same card (e.g. two Brinks cards) while others suggest getting one of each type (e.g. one Netspend, one Brinks, one Paypal, etc.)

Total Number of Netspend Cards

There’s a hard rule that you can only have a total of three Netspend cards backed by each unique bank. So you won’t be able to get Netspend, Ace, Control,  and Western Union, since that would be four cards all backed by Metabank. But you can get Netspend, Ace, and Control.

Many report a limit of five Netspend accounts total; you can get, for example, three cards backed by Metabank, and another two backed by Bancorp. While numerous people had success with five Netspend accounts total, some people start having problems with activation on card #4 & 5. On the flip-side, some even had success getting 6 total, within the confines of the 3-per-bank rule.

The system will not allow you to open two cards within 24-hours (clearing cookies won’t help). You’ll have to wait 24-hours between applications even when applying for distinct cards, e.g. Netspend and Brinks. This limit is apparently an address limit and even separate people at the same address can not order more than one card within 24-hours.

Other than the 24-hour wait, each unique individual should be able to open up numerous Netspend accounts, even multiple people from the same address.

Illustration

If we’ll assume the 3/5 rule mentioned above (three per bank, five total), we’ll give the following illustration. You can have:

  • One Netspend, one Ace Elite, and one Western Union card. These three are all issued by Metabank and this maxes you out on the three-per-bank limit mentioned above.
  • One Brinks and one H-E-B. While these are also Netspend cards, they are backed by a different bank (BofI). This will now max you out on the five-Netspend-total limit.
  • One Mango and one Insight. These accounts are completely unrelated to Netspend so you can have these accounts in addition to the Netspend accounts. (Possibly, you can even get multiples of these, as noted above.)

Total of at least seven 5+% savings accounts which will get you an APY of around 5% on $35,000.

Netspend Referral Program

Most of these cards have a referral program which allows us to refer new members to the prepaid card get a bonus.

  • Refer-a-friend and each of you will get a $20 bonus after the new member adds $40 to their account.

Only the Netspend-family cards have the referral program, not the Mango and Union Plus which are unassociated with Netspend.

Some people have been opening these prepaid accounts just for the sake of the $20 bonus. That may not be worth it for many, but it is an added little perk to go along with the 5% Savings Account. You’ll only get the $20 bonus if you use a referral link, not if you open an account directly.

The following cards are part of the Netspend referral bonus program: Netspend, Brinks, Western Union, Ace Elite, Control, and Paypal. H-E-B probably has the referral program as well.

Exceptions: Paypal Prepaid offers just a $5 bonus and Ace Elite offers just a $10 bonus.

Referral Limits

There is a limit of one referral bonus for the recipient across all Netspend-family cards within 180-days. This means that if you sign up for two of these cards on the same day (for example, Brinks and Netspend), you’ll only get the bonus for the first one. After 180-days, it resets and you can get another bonus.

There is no limit as to how many people you can refer, you can refer as many people you want and get the referrer bonus for each one. So long as the referred member is eligible for the bonus, you’ll get the bonus as well.

Please do not leave any referrals in the comments of this post. Instead, please visit our dedicated page for referrals on all Netspend-family products. You can pick up a referral there (to net the $20) and you can leave your referrals there. We also wrote more details there on the rules of the referral program.

Opening an Account

All of these prepaid cards don’t have any kind of credit check done and there is no hard pull or Chex inquiry done. You will have to verify your identity and give them your SSN/DOB, same as opening any bank account.

With regards to some of the Netspend cards, the process of opening an account is to signup with your name and address, without giving your SSN and other personal info. After getting the card, you’ll give in this info at the time of activating the card. Other cards (Paypal, Ace, and Mango) will require the SSN initially at the time of signup.

Do not try to ACH funds into your account before receiving and activating the card. It needs to be activated first.

Loading Funds

These prepaid accounts have a routing number and an account number, same as any checking account, and you can transfer funds to it the same way you would transfer funds between any two checking accounts.

All funds initially come into the prepaid account (via ACH or any other method such as cash loading) and are transferred to the attached Savings Account. There is no way to fund the Savings Account directly.

Things to keep in mind:

  • Since these are prepaid cards and not ordinary checking accounts, some banks may not allow transfers to it. My experience so far is that my banks are treating the prepaid account as an ordinary checking account.
  • We don’t recommend trying to transfer from a CapitalOne360 account since they’ve been known to have problems with people making transfers to prepaid accounts. Some mention not to use Chase or Discover either.
  • Bluebird/Serve/REDbird works for me with Mango, although one report mentions that it doesn’t work for Netspend.

What Counts as Direct Deposit?

Some of these cards need some form of direct deposit: the Brinks card needs a one-time $500 direct deposit to trigger the upgraded status which allows us to open the 5% savings account, and the Mango needs a $500 monthly direct deposit to make us eligible for the 6% interest rate.

In the past, any standard ACH transfer from another checking account has worked to satisfy these requirements. For the Mango account, ACH has been working to trigger the higher interest rate. As for Netspend, they used to allow any ACH transfer, but as of 1/22/16, a real payroll or government payment is required. This change does not affect those who were already upgraded.

Note that most Netspend cards don’t need any direct deposit at all to be able to open the savings account, but the Brinks car does need a one-time $500 direct deposit to enable you to then open the savings account.

Withdrawing Funds

‘How will I get the money out when I need it?’

People are often nervous about putting money in these prepaid accounts since they want to know that it’s easy to get the money out when necessary. Obviously, you could spend the money down on the prepaid card, but most of us don’t want to do that.

All the Netspend accounts come with an account/routing numbers and are ACH-enabled. Using the account/routing numbers, you can pull the money out into your linked bank account or you can pay your credit card bill on the card issuer’s website. (Be sure to first transfer the money from the savings account into the prepaid.)

ACH withdrawals seem to be working with the Mango cards as well.

Miscellaneous

Geographic Limitation: The Netspend accounts are not available for residents of Vermont. I have not found that restriction with regards to the Mango account.

Tax Implications: As with all bank accounts, you will receive a 1099INT form for all interest received.

ITIN User: You can open the account with an ITIN in place of a SSN, BUT you can’t get the upgraded account. Basically, the only reason you’d want to do this is if you actually want the prepaid account or if you want the $20 referral bonus; you won’t be able to get the 5% savings account. (This is the case with regards to Netspend accounts. Unclear what the Mango rules are.)

Mint.com Users: Most of these accounts can be added to Mint, but not all. Netspend, Brinks, Ace, and Mango show up in their system. HEB and Western Union can be added by choosing the Netspend option and using the HEB or Western Union credentials (HT: Kevin). Insight shows up but doesn’t add properly.

Options in Brief

We’ve written about each of these 5% savings options in dedicated posts. Here, we’ll try to round up the main details of each and we’ll include a link to the main post where you can read more.

Insight Card

Link to Main Post

This is the easiest with no direct deposit requirement. Downside is that it pays out quarterly as opposed to monthly.

Beware of the 90-day inactivity fee. Automate a monthly or by-monthly $1 ACH transfer from your regular checking account to the card to avoid that.

Mango

Link to Main Post

Link to Related Post

Pros

  • 6% interest rate, paid monthly
  • No inactivity fee to worry about

Cons

  • $3 monthly fee
  • Needs monthly direct deposit of $500
  • Needs a $1 balance on the card in order to be eligible for the high-interest rate

Netspend, Brinks, Western Union, Ace Elite

Link to Main Post 

These cards are great options since all you need to do is one initial direct-deposit/ACH-transfer and after that you’ll be eligible for the 5% interest rate. You can just leave the card as the default pay-as-you-go plan and it will end up completely fee-free.

Note, there is a stated 90-day inactivity fee. We wrote more about this in the original post on these cards.

H-E-B/Netspend

Link to Main Post

This account is identical in every respect to regular Netspend cards (Netspend, Brinks, etc.), with the single exception that it comes with an initial $2.95 signup fee.

Control

Link to Main Post 

This card closely resembles the regular Netspend cards and it’s also part of the regular Netspend referral program.

The key difference is that the Control card has a non-waivable $5 monthly fee, whereas with most of the other Netspend cards you can opt for the pay-as-you-go plan which leaves you completely fee-free.

Paypal Prepaid

Link to Main Post

This card is also part of the Netspend family. Two key differences between the Paypal Prepaid and the other Netspend cards:

  • The Paypal Prepaid has a non-waivable $4.95 monthly fee, whereas with most of the other Netspend cards you can opt for the pay-as-you-go plan which leaves you completely fee-free.
  • For the Paypal Prepaid you need a Paypal account and that account can be used to transfer money to and from the prepaid card account.

Union Plus

Link to Main Post

This card is currently unavailable for signup. It’s issued by the same company as the Mango card and most of the details mirror that of Mango. The interest rate is slightly lower at just 5.1% but without the $3 monthly fee, making the two cards a pretty comparable value overall.

Final Thoughts

The idea of juggling multiple accounts with $5,000 in each one is surely not fun, but many of us find it worthwhile. If we’d assume a standard APY of around 1%, you’ll get an extra ~4% utilizing these options, or around $200 annually per account.

Whether or not the $200 makes it worth the hassle is an individual decision. Personally, I wouldn’t do it for a single year, but since I hope that these will last for a while I decided it’s worthwhile to do the initial setup and hopefully reap the 5% rate for an extended period of time.

If you manage to max out seven cards with $5,000 each at ~5% rate, you’ll end up with ~$1750 annually, or $1400 more than you would have gotten at 1% interest rate.

For most people, I’d think that the best options would be as follows:

  • Netspend, Brinks, Western Union,  and Ace Elite would probably be the best options to start with.
  • The H-E-B is just as good as the others, with the single downside of the one-time $2.95 card ordering fee.
  • Mango is a great option if you’re willing to manage the $500 direct deposit requirement.
  • Paypal and Control are also something to think about, but they do come with a ~$5 monthly fee which really brings down the overall value of the account. At the very least, it would make sense to max out the other options first.

Other High-Interest Checking/Savings Accounts

The focus of this post is prepaid cards which come with 5+% interest rates. For the sake of having all info on one place, we’ll try to keep a list here of other reward and high-interest accounts.

See also An Introduction To Rewards Checking Accounts for more.



187
Leave a Reply

avatar
 

  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of

You never seize to amaze me with the quality and frequency of your content. Most people might say IF I had to pick one site…well to be honest I’ve stopped going to alot of other blogs because of the quality of this site.

Keey up the amazing work and know it’s very appreciated.

Never heard of this before, and will seriously consider getting the 4 starter cards you mention. If I have 2 addresses can I double up?

Chuck – I have to say it – this is a totally awesome guide to navigating this confusing territory. Sometimes it feels like you are trying to find your way thru a mine field – one wrong move and bang …..
THANK YOU!:)

FYI I just added the ACE Elite account to my Chase online banking to make the initial transfer (the card has already been received and activated) and it locked my Chase account. I just spent 15 minutes on the phone with Chase and they are asking me to visit a branch with 2 forms of ID as well as a statement from the ACE Elite bank account (which I obviously don’t have). This will be a pain to sort out, and in the meantime I can’t access my Chase account (which is my main bank account).

And yes, I know it was advised against 😉

What was advised against? To fund a new account with your chase account? people do this all the time with no issue so what’s going on in this case?

Chase doesn’t like NetSpend products. There’s a warning in the article.

Don’t use Chase. Chase closed my savings when I tried to add my Mango as an external transfer account, even though it was there before and I just readded it.

I’ve been using Chase to do ACH pulls from Mango and Santander to the account, so I guess they were spooked by it.

Yeah, the same thing happened to me when trying to add netspend. 1.5hrs on the phone and 30 minutes in a branch unfroze my account. I saw somewhere else that Chase has worked so figured I’d try out myself. It did not work…the Chase account is unfrozen, but is not connected to Netspend account.
I’m really disappointed with how Chase handled it (long hold times, several transfers to other hold lines, the CSR in-branch needing to be on hold for 20 minutes) and will be closing the checking account soon.

I have both the netSpend and Brinks ones already and transfer to and from Discover without issues. The $500 ACH push qualified me for the savings, and I received interest as expected at the end of the second quarter of 2015 (signed up a few months ago). I highly recommend these as an easy source of 5% interest on $5,000 and will be signing up for the ACE and WU ones as soon as I can find referral links.

Compeek are you using discover savings? or discover checking?

Discover Checking

Anybody get the following:

Sorry, we seem to be having trouble verifying your information. Please call us at 1-866-780-0041.

They are saying it has to do with my browser.

What does that mean? I am having the same issue that you are having where it says they are having trouble verifying my information. Also that 1-866-780-0041 phone number does not work.

Have you gotten this issue resolved?

How are people funding the $500 for DD for the Mango card?

For people with UnionPlus Accounts:

Just curious, has anyone received interest payments on their savings account on their August monthly statement? I was told by a UnionPlus CS that they will not be paying out interest on the savings account anymore. I don’t know if this is true or not, it wasn’t communicated in the end of July announcement that interest payments would terminate immediately.

This is what I see (opened a long time ago and haven’t messed with it):

Open a Mango Savings™ Account

Earn 6.00% APY† with Mango Savings™ if you’re enrolled in Mango’s Direct Deposit Service

Earn 2.00% APY† with Mango Savings™ if you’re NOT enrolled in Mango’s Direct Deposit Service

————————————-Earn 0.10% APY† on the portion of your balance over $5,000

Open your Savings Account today:

Open account with as little as $1
Up to 6 transfers out each month
Check your balance 24/7 from your mobile phone**
Transfer money using your mobile phone or our website**

Looks like NetSpend charges for everything — is there any way to check on the card/savings balance, other than going to a free ATM? I’d like to be able to do online. If you’ve already covered this and I overlooked it, my apologies. These NetSpend posts are great, btw. Thanks.

I hope I’m not the only reader out there who is this dumb: I didn’t realize Referral Codes are unique, that is, one-time-only use. So I used a Code that had already been used — I was the second person to have used that Code. Now I realize you can’t do that. So I’ve started over again, same contact info, using a Code that apparently hasn’t been used yet. Can you see any flaws in this course of action? Feeling mighty stupid right about now. Thanks.

So over the past couple weeks I’ve ordered:

NetSpend
NetSpend – Western Union
NetSpend – Brinks
NetSpend – HEB
NetSpend – Ace Elite

I activated the NetSpend (original), Western Union, and Brinks cards just fine. When I tried to log in to activate the HEB and Ace Elite, I kept getting a “We’re sorry, there is a problem with your account” error saying I needed to call them at 1-866-387-7363. After calling them and getting transferred to the fraud department, I had to answer multiple questions to prove my identity such as a state I grew up in, a street close to where I live, the county where I live, etc. After jumping through all those hoops (phone time: 45 minutes) they told me I can only have 3 NetSpend accounts and that is why the other two accounts were placed on hold. I told them that the limit should be 3 per BANK, not 3 TOTAL. The representative checked with her supervisor and they closed the HEB and Ace Elite accounts. Not sure how people are getting more than 3 cards, I was shut down pretty quickly.

Do all 5 of them pay the same rate? This is good to know as I was under the assumption we could open 1 of each.

Yes, they all pay the same rate.

I opened the same five accounts as you did and I had the same issue. I was apparently only allowed to have three active cards as well so I had to close two of them. I brought up the two different banks as well and Netspend had the same response that they gave you.

Jeremy, you might want to wait a few weeks then try opening an HEB account. That’s what I did, so now I have 4 active accounts. When I tried to do the same for the Ace Elite (the only one I’m missing) it gave me an error when I tried to have the card sent to me.

I used a different address for the HEB card.

It appears I’ve encountered the same. First 4 went smooth, only after applying for 5th at HEB did things go awry. Now login will not work on any. Will have to wait until I receive cards to sort it out I guess.

Was unable to fund Netspend (MetaBank) from PNC. Received “invalid ABA Number” error

But believe Brinks (BoFi) is not blocked by PNC

Something about this whole NetSpend thing isn’t “right”: I’ve spent three days trying to get my card activated, but their website won’t accept my info, and their customer service phone line only allows you to activate a card, which I did, but then they tell you you’ll need to activate the card (after I just got through doing so, with them). They have no Technical Support Department, or so I was told by Customer Service, so I can’t get help with online access issue(s). That is, I won’t be able to fund this account because I can’t even activate it. Maybe I’m the only one having these issues, but I’ll bet not.

I just opened a NetSpend account and I’m reading the cardholder agreement. It states, “Cost to Open Account/Card Purchase Fee: Fee will be determined and assessed by operator of retail location. In no event will the fee exceed $9.95”

What does this mean?

Back to Top ↑